Message from @SilverLining

Discord ID: 493987242755489803


2018-09-25 03:24:56 UTC  

What kind of groups are we talking about? And what is "an equal starting point?"

2018-09-25 03:25:38 UTC  

Is everyone equal before the law, or do you mean equally financially speaking? Are we talking about foreigners or your own people?

2018-09-25 03:25:56 UTC  

Those are all different questions

2018-09-25 03:26:17 UTC  

" we should strive to produce the most happiness - the most pleasure - for the most people"

This is what everyone strives for

2018-09-25 03:26:26 UTC  

This is what fascists strive for

2018-09-25 03:26:34 UTC  

This is what Marxists strive for

2018-09-25 03:26:40 UTC  

This is what liberals strive for

2018-09-25 03:26:56 UTC  

Heavily debateable

2018-09-25 03:27:02 UTC  

Actually not even debateable, just false

2018-09-25 03:27:11 UTC  

Kinda don't think Hitler wanted to make der Juden happy

2018-09-25 03:27:24 UTC  

Kinda don't think white supremacists care much about how happy non-whites are

2018-09-25 03:27:35 UTC  

and both before the law and financially, more or less

2018-09-25 03:27:43 UTC  

As without one or the other, such equity won't exist

2018-09-25 03:27:43 UTC  

Counterpoint: What did Hitler think eliminating the Jews would do for everyone else? @SilverLining

2018-09-25 03:27:53 UTC  

He thought it would make the world better, no?

2018-09-25 03:28:08 UTC  

He strove to make Aryans/Germanics happy

2018-09-25 03:28:11 UTC  

Not all people

2018-09-25 03:28:18 UTC  

I mean, he didn't intend to eliminate the slavs, iirc

2018-09-25 03:28:23 UTC  

he intended to use them as slave labor

2018-09-25 03:28:53 UTC  

It's striving to increase the happiness of a particular group

2018-09-25 03:28:56 UTC  

Rather than of everyone

2018-09-25 03:29:00 UTC  

"Kinda don't think white supremacists care much about how happy non-whites are"

You're looking at it the wrong way, they believe helping other races is going to harm more people than help

2018-09-25 03:29:12 UTC  

So like

2018-09-25 03:29:26 UTC  

Lynching African Americans isn't making African Americans less happy

2018-09-25 03:30:17 UTC  

You can easily argue they intend to make certain subsets happier

2018-09-25 03:30:21 UTC  

But not humanity as a whole

2018-09-25 03:30:30 UTC  

Well those people do it with the intention of "keeping blacks in their place" and from "hurting white people" etc

Most evil men throughout history had a selfless aspect to their ideology @SilverLining

2018-09-25 03:30:36 UTC  

Russian Empire should be revived

2018-09-25 03:30:38 UTC  

some kind, at least

2018-09-25 03:30:52 UTC  

Why do you think Hitler killed so many people?

2018-09-25 03:30:59 UTC  

Because he thought the world would be better if he did

2018-09-25 03:31:01 UTC  

To "help" another group of people

2018-09-25 03:31:13 UTC  

Again, he didn't really care about said other group

2018-09-25 03:31:16 UTC  

or their wellbeing

2018-09-25 03:31:21 UTC  

Which is what I'm trying to emphasize.

2018-09-25 03:31:30 UTC  

Okay, well then that's not the same as "striving for the greatest possible happiness for all"

2018-09-25 03:31:39 UTC  

There is a fine line, but it's there

2018-09-25 03:32:17 UTC  

"the greatest possible happiness for all" would include incorporating everyone, regardless of any innate factors

2018-09-25 03:32:19 UTC  

The logic that classical liberals used, was along the lines of, the poor should not be helped because it will extend their suffering to everyone else, right?

2018-09-25 03:32:29 UTC  

rather than just a portion of people

2018-09-25 03:33:08 UTC  

And what if one argues that doing so is a net negative?