Message from @The Enlightened Shepherd
Discord ID: 302101425540825098
IS GERMAN NATURE "FORM AND HIERARCHY"? IT IS MANY THINGS
too reductive
MORE LIKELY
WE SHOULD LOOK AT THE THREE EUROPES
both categories, DNA and culture, are incomplete
@fallot I DO NOT THINK SO; WITHIN THAT THERE IS INDIVIDUAL CHOICE, BUT ONLY W/N SCOPE DEFINED BY DNA
they don't cover the realms of human existence
a combination, ethnoculture, is a workaround
ETHNOCULTURE IS JUST AN "AND" APPLIED
AND MISSES THE ETHNIC ORIGINS OF CULTURE
THE LEFT THINKS CULTURE COMES BEFORE ETHNICITY
culture itself will have a selecting effect
HAIDT SAYS A FEEDBACK LOOP
so there are cultural effects on ethny
I WROTE ABOUT THIS EXTENSIVELY AND SO TO AVOID BORING YOU, WILL NOT REPEAT
@diversity_is_racism This is again, true, but when understood with flexibility and when understood as a larger, general picture
But this is preciselly what lead you to describe Russian society as a "peasant" society, as if peasants were it's essential component !
If we are speaking of strictly types of labor
Then, I pointed out that EVERY society was peasant including European
to whih you replied circularly, "but Europe had form"
The overall amount of phenotypic variation that generic variation can actually account for is very small and almost irrelevant. Linking societies to DNA doesn't fit.
I must say, that while I certainly prefer even that kind of weltanschaaung to what we have today
what are you talking about @༺པརབྱར།བསངཇ༻ ?
Germanic Folkish order where everything is subject to the imperative of a massive genetical folkish gene pool
Is deviant
The idea that German society is due to German Dna. (Insert other societies as needed)
And more importantly, Germany, until Hitler, NEVER subscribed to that worldview
yeah, it is deviant
Or otherwise, Bavarian ruling elite would've never existed and German society would be entirely lead by Northerners which was not the case
Pomeranian peasants for example
PEASANT SOCIETY = FORMED OF PEASANTS NEARLY ENTIRELY
Were highly appreciated by German society as hard working people
EUROPE HAD SOCIAL TIERS
But they were still peasants
WHAT IS THE FASCINATION WITH GERMANY?
NO, MANY OF THEM WERE KSHATRIYA OR BRAHMIN
HENCE EUROPE'S SUCCESS OVER RUSSIA
IN ADDITION TO GENETIC FACTORS (MISCEGENATION)
Define Europe's success over Russia
BETTER QUALITY OUTPUT