Message from @Dutch Plan Der Linde

Discord ID: 686458839205543952


2020-03-09 06:11:09 UTC  

I think 15 is probably too much

2020-03-09 06:11:31 UTC  

you can strike a balance

2020-03-09 06:11:41 UTC  

without fucking over the lower class completely

2020-03-09 06:12:04 UTC  

There's alot of variables to a wage of an employee

2020-03-09 06:12:21 UTC  

I couldnt list them all

2020-03-09 06:14:05 UTC  

"if you can't pay people enough to live maybe you shouldn't be in business"
but you said if you cant pay your employees a livable wage you shouldnt be a business.
there are a lot of for example family owned bakers that have a few employees and make enough to pay the owner's bills and the paychecks of its employees. If 15 dollars was implemented to be a minimum wage what would stop the businesses from letting go half their employees to pay the livable wage.

2020-03-09 06:14:43 UTC  

Wouldnt this just leave some Americans without jobs?

2020-03-09 06:15:29 UTC  

well it's a complex issue people make the mistake of thinking this is basic economics when it's not

2020-03-09 06:15:48 UTC  

Seattle has $15 minimum wage so just look at them for example

2020-03-09 06:16:18 UTC  

I think more likely is a reduction in hours and understaffing

2020-03-09 06:17:02 UTC  

and if it's a family business you have more kids to slave away for free obviously

2020-03-09 06:17:55 UTC  

but yeah even with a mom and pop your wages are a part of your expenses, not the whole pie

2020-03-09 06:18:13 UTC  

from the perspective of the employee it's their whole pie

2020-03-09 06:19:37 UTC  

but yeah that argument is made a lot and I think it's shit because it's a scarcity mindset

2020-03-09 06:19:49 UTC  

if you're in business you should be making money hand over fist sweet profit

2020-03-09 06:19:57 UTC  

why the fuck do you have a bakery if you're breaking even

2020-03-09 06:20:05 UTC  

you should close anyways you're wasting time

2020-03-09 06:20:56 UTC  

if the only reason your business is alive is because you pay your employees less than what they need to survive then maybe your business is the one that should die

2020-03-09 06:22:01 UTC  

Well thatz what the whole workers rights movement was all about in the late 1800's

2020-03-09 06:22:04 UTC  

Also

2020-03-09 06:22:21 UTC  

Its not exactly an ideal job to keep at mcdonalds

2020-03-09 06:22:33 UTC  

Because its more of a teenager starting job

2020-03-09 06:22:45 UTC  

So no shit your not going to be paid the most

2020-03-09 06:22:53 UTC  

Because anyone can get that job

2020-03-09 06:23:04 UTC  

also a common argument but it's wrong

2020-03-09 06:23:22 UTC  

So how is it wrong?

2020-03-09 06:23:31 UTC  

90.7% of people on minimum wage are over the age of 20

2020-03-09 06:23:44 UTC  

I think its interesting how you brought up Seattle as an example of a 15 dollar minimum wage. This only applies to companies who have over 500 employees. Meaning if you are below that criteria 15 dollars wouldnt matter. But I used a bakery as an example of how a 15 dollar minimum wage could effect small businesses. But my whole premise is, it causes less competition for those unappealing jobs like trash collecting or disgusting low paying jobs.

2020-03-09 06:23:50 UTC  

over half are educated

2020-03-09 06:24:27 UTC  

Are you talking about worldwide? Or just the US?

2020-03-09 06:24:37 UTC  

US

2020-03-09 06:25:02 UTC  

I highly doubt that number is right

2020-03-09 06:25:17 UTC  

I don't think there is much competition for trash collecting as it is

2020-03-09 06:25:28 UTC  

If it was then the us wouldnt be the top richest nation in the world

2020-03-09 06:25:28 UTC  

pretty sure custodians are fairly well paid considering the job

2020-03-09 06:25:47 UTC  

Probably about 30% are paid minimum

2020-03-09 06:25:48 UTC  

it's not $7/hr

2020-03-09 06:27:42 UTC  

increasing the pay for collecting trash doesn't make people want to do the job less...

2020-03-09 06:27:42 UTC  

Well take a look a full time garbage collector vs a full time working at mcdonalds
mcdonalds full time salary is around 22k a year compared to a garbage collector which is 37k a year
sure many people might not want those disgusting jobs or there even being a massive competition for it. But there is competition for those higher paying jobs

2020-03-09 06:28:33 UTC  

Theres alot of competition nowadays for gaming for example

2020-03-09 06:28:38 UTC  

It's super fierce