Message from @Beemann

Discord ID: 470004214907535360


2018-07-20 19:36:57 UTC  

but you also cannot just make up your own stuff, at least not without explaining it.

2018-07-20 19:37:06 UTC  

because then people will not understand you

2018-07-20 19:37:11 UTC  

and you will be isolated

2018-07-20 19:42:38 UTC  

Languages do evolve, thus we need language reforms now and then

2018-07-20 19:43:02 UTC  

But we also need the "standard" language to conduct business without misunderstanding

2018-07-20 21:14:03 UTC  

reporting back.... yeah its not that lefty, lol was jsut conservatives that ken burns is a left himself XD

2018-07-20 21:14:14 UTC  

the vietnam war

2018-07-20 22:54:57 UTC  

Language needs to evolve for utility. When you reduce utility (figuratively using literally) you are not growing the language

2018-07-20 22:56:04 UTC  

You are actually making it harder to communicate certain ideas

2018-07-20 23:02:16 UTC  

languages simultaneously increase and decrease in simplicity in different areas

2018-07-20 23:03:21 UTC  

Sure, but you need to be cognizant of where that's happening and why, or you might find your future a little doubleplus ungood comrade

2018-07-20 23:04:45 UTC  

languages have generally evolved very organically, if something would ruin the language it simply won't catch on

2018-07-20 23:04:50 UTC  

unless you force it

2018-07-20 23:05:33 UTC  

Have is not an assurance of will

2018-07-20 23:05:35 UTC  

although sometimes you do end up with tibetan, and nobody ever wants their language to turn into tibetan

2018-07-20 23:06:45 UTC  

given the amount of time languages have been evolving, i can confidently say we will not fuck up any language unless we start manually fucking with it

2018-07-20 23:07:21 UTC  

Right, and that's the danger I'm rather specifically referring to

2018-07-20 23:07:38 UTC  

so, manually fucking with language??

2018-07-20 23:07:52 UTC  

Do you remember the "old" definition of racism?

2018-07-20 23:08:20 UTC  

oh yeah, the trend of trying to intentionally redefine words is certainly very very bad

2018-07-20 23:08:57 UTC  

Yes, and to that extent I think keeping terminology in the clear is important

2018-07-20 23:10:58 UTC  

sorry, i jumped in in the middle and, given your figuratively/literally example thought you were talking about the excessive use of hyperbole in english, not the malicious redefining of words

2018-07-20 23:11:57 UTC  

No I just mean redefining at either the loss of utility wholesale, or for partisan purposes

2018-07-20 23:12:25 UTC  

I honestly don't think we gain anything by losing the word literally to emphasis, but it was just an example of how utility can be lost

2018-07-20 23:14:19 UTC  

well, for the literally example, it will eventually reach the point where literally and figuratively will be synonyms and we will be using a new word that means something similar enough to the current definition of literally

2018-07-20 23:14:34 UTC  

and then at some point either literally or figuratively will probably fall out of use

2018-07-20 23:15:02 UTC  

language is a big dumb ride that usually doesn't actually go anywhere lol

2018-07-20 23:15:21 UTC  

I think it *can* go somewhere

2018-07-20 23:15:41 UTC  

It just goes there occasionally, and in spite of the userbase

2018-07-20 23:15:52 UTC  

yeah, it takes an absurd amount of time though. most changes are just going in circles

2018-07-21 01:11:38 UTC  

There's also organic changes in a word that are not so good.

Like the continual redefinition of violence to where now words are violence

2018-07-21 01:12:38 UTC  

that's not organic, that's one of those changes that are being forced

2018-07-21 01:14:01 UTC  

Yeah, very few people actually believe that, but the loud socjus minority make it seem bigger than it really is

2018-07-21 01:14:15 UTC  

But that's things functioning as intended

2018-07-21 01:30:48 UTC  

I disagree. Violence has overgone *braodening* as it's called in linguistics.

https://www.thoughtco.com/broadening-semantic-generalization-1689181

2018-07-21 01:31:28 UTC  

Only within a clique

2018-07-21 01:31:35 UTC  

This is convenient for some people, but the mental-health nuts on Tumblr seem to *honestly believe* that words and ideas that cause distress are equivalent to physical violence (and will point to psychology stuff to try and make that point)

2018-07-21 01:31:47 UTC  

It's a growing clique though.

2018-07-21 01:32:49 UTC  

I don't think it is, tbh

2018-07-21 01:33:20 UTC  

The lefty purity spiral is real

2018-07-21 01:33:47 UTC  

They hemorrhage moderates the more hard-line they get