this is not what happened in Israel

they cooperated

And they won’t give it back

small scale communes were possible at a time before globalism

Correct

native americans for example

tribes

@ImP0steR how you gonna seize the means of production?

nope actually because of globalism and better way of communications you can make it on a larger scale

GG @ImP0steR, you just advanced to level 8!

tribes were hostiles

cuz of lack of communications

they didn't cooperate

ye at a larger scale

thats what were sayin

at small scales communes can exist but at broader scales it wont

people form group

We live in a society

identities based on culture language etc

variety of ideals

many small communes together create a large scale

it differ itself from the soviet union

that wants to put all in the same group

this failed

those are 2 different type of large scale

failed cause equality at a large scale can only exist if its enforced but then the enforcer has grossly disproportionate power

yes, and this is not what I'm talking about

🆙 | **ImP0steR leveled up!**

keep the communes small and dependent of each other

it's sort of mix of free market with communism

worlds too globalized now

instead of nationalizing everything and own all the goods

has been for thousands of years

theoretically sure it could work

but practically it cant because not all humans are going to agree to the game

it's something that might happen on a catastrophic era

some group is going to form and want to take over another to gain power

such is the game of human history

such as the moment nations won't be able to return their debt

people will choose a new lifestyle

and live in communes by choice