Message from @halfthink
Discord ID: 522751714743287818
We're flawed humans and or government is flawed as we are. But overall, yes.
There have been a lot of failings along the way, and even currently
But yes, we still have a Constitutional government
The fact we (more or less) calmly handed power from Obama to Trump is proof of the beauty of our system.
And the fact two or six years from now we will (more or less) calmly hand power to someone else, possibly as antithetical to Trump as Obama is amazing.
The swamp is undrainable, there was no danger there.
We are well past the possibility of top down reform
You call it a swamp. I call it the greatest achievement of mankind.
Warts and all
And God knows there are a LOT of warts
The administrative state is what is meant by the swamp
I disagree
Or if it is, then we agree we have problems
The Administrative State as it exists now is almost antithetical to Constitutional Government
Constitutional Government is about limits - diffusion of authority. The administrative state is about aggregation of authority.
```"Nothing is more misleading, then, than the conventional formulae of historians who represent the achievement of a powerful state as the culmination of cultural evolution: it as often marked its end. In this respect students of early history were overly impressed and greatly misled by monuments and documents left by the holders of political power, whereas the true builders of the extended order, who as often as not created the wealth that made the monuments possible, left less tangible and ostentatious testimonies to their achievement."
-Hayek.```
I agree with Hayek.
Monarchies were more accountable to the people, because you only needed to chop off one head.
But Constitutional Government and "powerful state" are not exactly compatible
Feudalism sounds more appealing every day.
https://mises.org/wire/feudalism-system-private-law
```"If I must be a slave, I would rather be privately owned, than publicly owned"
-Hans-Hermann Hoppe.```
Once again I agree with Marc Thiessen. That the Dems are refusing to dicker with a transactional president like Trump is going to drive me nuts.
Finally had a chance to catch up on the Brexit news from yesterday. Totally unsurprised by the result of the no-confidence vote. No one else wants to be PM that most Tories would want to see in the post. May wins by default because she's the most palatable of those who will actually do it, not because anyone really wants her there.
Anyway, with this out of the way we at least know that this is it. May can't be challenged again for a year. I suspect there may have been Tories who wrote letters to bring up the no-confidence vote now so that it would be impossible to hang it over May's head for another year.
As I understand it, the only way to change the playing field now would be for those 117 Tory no votes to join with Labor and the Scots to force the government down entirely.
How uninspiring. But then, the British people have rarely inspired confidence in recent years.
But those 117 could well lose their MP elections, so they'd have to risk giving up power. I doubt we'll see that happen.
So we now see if May's tenuous position will allow her to extract anything else out of Europe. If so, this theater is all worth it for Britain. If not, and I expect not, then it's all up to Parliament. May's deal or no deal...or I suppose May could just rescind the Article 50 call and reset everything.
No deal is still very much on the table, which I thought would inspire some here.
Honestly, if I were a betting girl, which I am not, being notoriously risk-averse, I would bet that Britain will end up falling out because no one can come to a decision.
At this point, no deal is probably the best option.
But no one likes watching their leader flub policy. It shows weakness.
No deal was always the best option
The British will need to decide that.
No deal is the only way to let the British have the most say in everything else moving forward.
The only deal the EU is even willing to accept is worse than no brexit at all
The British already decided, Brexit means Brexit!