palaestra_debates

Discord ID: 680587502918041623


9,620 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev | Page 4/97 | Next

2020-02-22 22:14:42 UTC

There's really only one solution, people must create a database of general knowledge and recent scientific papers.

2020-02-22 22:15:00 UTC

Like wiki, but for profit, and without any state subsidization.

2020-02-22 22:15:23 UTC

They must also create a student-teacher network around that platform.

2020-02-22 22:15:36 UTC

there should be multiple of them to force competition

2020-02-22 22:15:51 UTC

Exactly.

2020-02-22 22:16:07 UTC

The problem is, however, that public schools drive the prices of those private organizations up.

2020-02-22 22:16:38 UTC

So I don't know what the solution is tbh.

2020-02-22 22:16:44 UTC

it's like that in every thing tho. even in health care. food

2020-02-22 22:17:27 UTC

everything that the goverment touches. kinda weird. I've spoke about this with the both of you before and you both disagreed with me. Don't know why you changed your mind

2020-02-22 22:18:10 UTC

Maybe you're mistaking me for someone else? I've been against public education for years.

2020-02-22 22:18:35 UTC

i think the solution would be 2 steps. stop making school attendance mandatory. and then cut all funding to every school. it will be hell for the first few years but it will get better

2020-02-22 22:19:11 UTC

there are better ways. but that's just the quickest one

2020-02-22 22:19:24 UTC

They'll never do any of that, it'd be a career killer for the vast majority of politicians.

2020-02-22 22:19:56 UTC

Sorry guys, have you two discussed **opportunity cost**, yet?

2020-02-22 22:20:08 UTC

In what context?

2020-02-22 22:20:42 UTC

Looong formation time and lack of practical experience vs Homeschooling

2020-02-22 22:21:06 UTC

Pardon?

2020-02-22 22:21:22 UTC

I'm not following, sorry

2020-02-22 22:21:28 UTC

me either

2020-02-22 22:21:38 UTC

So a child that can read and is mature emotionally can study higher stuff

2020-02-22 22:21:55 UTC

Start and finish school sooner

2020-02-22 22:22:11 UTC

Any better?

2020-02-22 22:22:15 UTC

school shouldn't be a place to become emotionally mature. that should be at home

2020-02-22 22:22:25 UTC

I can follow now. What's your argument?

2020-02-22 22:22:29 UTC

Yes, true

2020-02-22 22:24:31 UTC

Well, if a student and their parents really spending good cash on really great education (given the child has what it takes) they'll think double where to invest their cash.

However the schools are absolutely completely reliant on the satisfaction of their clients.

2020-02-22 22:25:26 UTC

Well the kids are the product they're producing

2020-02-22 22:25:37 UTC

If there's no urge, people lose out on opportunity cost and falsely believe that time passing by is fiiiine.

2020-02-22 22:26:04 UTC

I don't see why that'd be the case

2020-02-22 22:26:21 UTC

Also, you'd have tons of really great reviews on schools and teachers before you decided to pay for the services

2020-02-22 22:26:33 UTC

Do you mean if school is not mandatory then parents will neglect their children's education?

2020-02-22 22:27:18 UTC

Well they'll be competing with homeschools and other private schools.

2020-02-22 22:28:16 UTC

The public sector doesn't compete. It dies or takes over, but it never competes.

2020-02-22 22:28:32 UTC

Nah, I think if parents are allowed they'll choose the most proven route @ETBrooD

2020-02-22 22:28:56 UTC

that's why i said it shouldn't be mandatory

2020-02-22 22:29:15 UTC

There is no "most proven route", because every child is different.

2020-02-22 22:29:32 UTC

Even the most adaptable school is not neccessarily the best.

2020-02-22 22:29:48 UTC

Oh, absolutely

2020-02-22 22:30:05 UTC

I meant in *low resolution*

2020-02-22 22:30:07 UTC

I don't think we should be looking at kids as kids. Lets look at them like they were phones. so emotions don't get in the way

2020-02-22 22:30:29 UTC

Hahaha
No
Let's not pls

2020-02-22 22:30:33 UTC

Yeah lets not

2020-02-22 22:30:49 UTC

That has nothing to do with emotional bias

2020-02-22 22:31:15 UTC

It's going to become emotional bias i believe

2020-02-22 22:31:42 UTC

But i'll wait and see how you guys procced. I'm going to be watching for abit

2020-02-22 22:32:42 UTC

My niece (age 8) goes to a school that allows her to fast forward or repeat individual classes

2020-02-22 22:33:03 UTC

@Kingy200
Also man, thanks for the earlier! Nice one

2020-02-22 22:33:03 UTC

Most parents in that school like that system, but some don't and pull their children out

2020-02-22 22:33:32 UTC

Fuk em

2020-02-22 22:33:38 UTC

I think it's impossible to know which system is best for children. Some flourish under a rigid structure, some don't.

2020-02-22 22:34:01 UTC

You must always think with the head of the kids
What do they need and benefit from

2020-02-22 22:34:03 UTC

That's why I think the best "system" is simply the free market.

2020-02-22 22:34:21 UTC

So parents can send their children anywhere they like.

2020-02-22 22:34:41 UTC

And they have many different systems to pick from, because that only exists in a free market.

2020-02-22 22:34:48 UTC

True

2020-02-22 22:35:14 UTC

That's why I said what I did in broken French

2020-02-22 22:35:51 UTC

But perhaps online university is going to be huge one day

2020-02-22 22:36:24 UTC

Well... that heavily depends on the subject I think

2020-02-22 22:36:42 UTC

Math can be taught very well online, not really any problems

2020-02-22 22:36:51 UTC

Hahaha
True

2020-02-22 22:36:58 UTC

Biology however not so much

2020-02-22 22:37:31 UTC

Or cooking, lab, photo lab

2020-02-22 22:38:14 UTC

Yeah, and human interactions can also help some people even when it's a dry subject.

2020-02-22 22:38:28 UTC

Although with the advance of VR and Musk neurolink... Hehe

2020-02-22 22:38:48 UTC

Well ok, that far into the future it might be possible, sure ๐Ÿ˜›

2020-02-22 22:39:16 UTC

I'm trying to think of a solution right this very moment. A way to significantly improve education.

2020-02-22 22:39:46 UTC

Public education is extremely slow at adopting good teaching methods.

2020-02-22 22:39:51 UTC

Make it punishable for teachers to lie

2020-02-22 22:40:05 UTC

Uh... already is

2020-02-22 22:40:21 UTC

You can sue any teacher you like

2020-02-22 22:40:43 UTC

Ok, how about this


Ban, preferential treatment in class.

2020-02-22 22:41:09 UTC

That's silly

2020-02-22 22:41:12 UTC

Meh, idk. I think that's demanding too much.

2020-02-22 22:41:42 UTC

At some point human failure and bias just comes into play no matter how hard we try to stop it.

2020-02-22 22:41:43 UTC

<:swet:671404160393936948>

2020-02-22 22:41:59 UTC

As a guidance

2020-02-22 22:42:01 UTC

The key I think is that the system is optimized so that human failure is the *only* failure possible.

2020-02-22 22:42:21 UTC

Not a rule. Something to aspire for, not to live by.

2020-02-22 22:43:45 UTC

preferential treatment will be hard because it's private. but it will still happen. but hardly

2020-02-22 22:44:26 UTC

I think we can much better reduce preferential treatment by reducing the incentive to do so.

2020-02-22 22:44:30 UTC

Yeah but teachers need to be accountable, not over the rules. They can't only make up the rules if others are paying for it. <:hypersmugon:544638648721604608>

2020-02-22 22:44:54 UTC

Basically negating the incentive instead of using negative or positive reinforcement.

2020-02-22 22:45:08 UTC

yes the school holds them accountable. the parents hold the school accountable

2020-02-22 22:45:26 UTC

Probably ETBrooD both

2020-02-22 22:45:32 UTC

Well I think schools aren't held accountable *because* they receive subsidization.

2020-02-22 22:45:46 UTC

Reduce AND instate new ones

2020-02-22 22:46:16 UTC

The free market holds people accountable naturally. They simply fail more often.

2020-02-22 22:46:27 UTC

@Kingy200
There's no accountability towards the parents

2020-02-22 22:46:48 UTC

Funny but the school has responsibility to the government first

2020-02-22 22:47:40 UTC

taking in a private market. yes there is. The child is less likely to get a good education which means less pay. which means the parents don't got someone to look after them when their older

2020-02-22 22:48:15 UTC

So u have to get rid of pensions

2020-02-22 22:49:03 UTC

I'd rather have parents revise the teaching syllabus in its outlines

2020-02-22 22:49:33 UTC

Because parents see what the current market values

2020-02-22 22:49:50 UTC

Not choosing for the kids but for the syllabus

2020-02-22 22:50:25 UTC

What % of tax did we get rid of btw

2020-02-22 22:50:57 UTC

With the education system revision?

2020-02-22 22:51:06 UTC

yes

2020-02-22 22:51:57 UTC

Depending.
If you only take the monetary its maybe 3% in my guesstimate... Without looking anything up... Sowwy

2020-02-22 22:52:23 UTC

what if you get rid of taxes aswell

2020-02-22 22:52:39 UTC

i mean pensions

9,620 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev | Page 4/97 | Next