Message from @rivenator12113

Discord ID: 655145137046945793


2019-12-13 20:29:05 UTC  

''De León ascribed the work to Shimon bar Yochai ("Rashbi"), a rabbi of the 2nd century during the Roman persecution[5] ''

2019-12-13 20:29:22 UTC  

Mhm, did you read the next sentence?

2019-12-13 20:29:31 UTC  

as·cribe
/əˈskrīb/
Learn to pronounce
verb
past tense: ascribed; past participle: ascribed
attribute something to (a cause).

2019-12-13 20:29:43 UTC  

Where they say it can’t possible have been him because it references things that happened after the Talmud?

2019-12-13 20:30:00 UTC  

If you’re going to be an asshole, you might want to have your facts straight

2019-12-13 20:30:04 UTC  

together with the circumstance that it refers to historical events of the post-Talmudical period,

2019-12-13 20:30:13 UTC  

When you read that, what does that mean to you?

2019-12-13 20:30:30 UTC  

@floridaswamptrash which makes arguing about religion pretty much pointless

2019-12-13 20:30:39 UTC  

De Leon never said he completed the Zohar, he compiled all the works that was passed down and published it

2019-12-13 20:30:57 UTC  

Yes, good work, that’s correct

2019-12-13 20:31:15 UTC  

Now did you read the entire article like a good boy?

2019-12-13 20:31:18 UTC  

Finish your homework

2019-12-13 20:31:18 UTC  

He gave the works credit to a 2nd century rabbi

2019-12-13 20:31:31 UTC  

Mhm, and what does the article say about that assertion?

2019-12-13 20:32:06 UTC  

Do you need me to answer that for you, or can you read all the letters yourself?

2019-12-13 20:32:10 UTC  

ok im positive im getting trolled lmao

2019-12-13 20:32:27 UTC  

2019-12-13 20:32:34 UTC  

@Sassy Undeniably Possibility

2019-12-13 20:32:46 UTC  

Well you’re being a petulant child so that’s how I’m treating you

2019-12-13 20:32:51 UTC  

But can you answer the question?

2019-12-13 20:32:52 UTC  

@Deleted User publisher != creator of the book

2019-12-13 20:32:56 UTC  

Did you read the whole article?

2019-12-13 20:32:59 UTC  

Just mute Sophia, insults

2019-12-13 20:33:02 UTC  

Mhm yes good job honey

2019-12-13 20:33:13 UTC  

well when you realize it is just a belief you then gain perspective and put it in it's proper place

2019-12-13 20:33:13 UTC  

Now did you finish the whole article like a big boy?

2019-12-13 20:33:24 UTC  

Where it says that attribution can’t possibly be accurate

2019-12-13 20:33:35 UTC  

Because it references things in the post Talmudic period?

2019-12-13 20:33:45 UTC  

Post-Talmudic means “after the Talmud”

2019-12-13 20:33:45 UTC  

she doesn't know anything about history, she attributed the talmud to the middle ages then said the zorah was created in the middle ages wtf

2019-12-13 20:33:52 UTC  

Let me know if you’re still following along

2019-12-13 20:34:00 UTC  

The Zohar was created in the Middle Ages

2019-12-13 20:34:09 UTC  

The Talmud was created in late antiquity

2019-12-13 20:34:16 UTC  

seems to me this discussion should happen in the religious section

2019-12-13 20:34:24 UTC  

I was confusing the Talmud with the combined Talmud and mishna, it was my mistake

2019-12-13 20:34:36 UTC  

But my point still stands

2019-12-13 20:34:44 UTC  

in your head

2019-12-13 20:34:49 UTC  

Ok, so we’ve proved that the Zohar was written after the Talmud

2019-12-13 20:34:57 UTC  

Mhm, what part of my point doesn’t stand honey?

2019-12-13 20:35:04 UTC  

Can you use your words like a big boy?

2019-12-13 20:35:20 UTC  

Maybe make a full syllogism like they’re teaching you in your freshman logic class?