i will reply

The argument is essentially theological fatalism, its just that your conclusion is concerning the implication being that god cannot therefore be omnipotent
And all im saying is, that the conclusion is untrue because the argument is untrue, and the argument is untrue because its formally invalid
Formal invalidity entails the absence of an adequate inference rule, and an inference rule in propositional logic is THE thing which connects the conclusion and the premises
and since the conclusion and the premises arent connected, the argument is generally useless

What the fuck

Where did you rebutt me

Its untrue, because its untrue

Yeah thats definitely what I said

It illogical because its nonsensical

I said its untrue because its formally invalid

No

I never said that lol

stop fucking strawmaning me

Explain how its formally invalid plz

Sure

Theological fatalism basically states that god knows X therefore necessarily X will happen
However, thats an invalid inference rule, since god knowing X will happen does not mean X will happen necessarily

no, im sorry but if i being knows everything AND THEN CREATES A BEING he must know everything that being will do. Do you follow and accept this?

I already said yes, and I already explained how it doesn't follow that free will is an illusion from that

X will happen =/= x will happen necessarily

i just literally did lol

Okay, well. How does a being that knows all make something with choice?

This is the same issue reworded

The same answer

God knowing x will happen isnt x hapening necessarily, therefore there is room for not doing x and doing y

I don't understand ofvo's point

yes but

no

Because then I DONT KNOW ALL

Right?

No? How does that follow

wtf man

why

how the fuck

this bothers me a lot

You seem to think that just because god knows X, x will necessarily happen as X has already happened which isnt true

as me wanking is only true when i wank

God operates beyond time itself

He's not bound by time

thus the objection doesn't apply since he's beyond time itself, and hence no "necessarily x will happen" as x didnt already happen since there was no time to begin with

since "x will happen" implies time

I always get here with folks. Its a binary. You are omnipotent and omniscient and know all or you dont.

If you do, its impossible to create something with freewill because in reality you know everything it will do before it does it. If you say god only knows potentials then god ISNT omnipotent.
unless you change definition.

Dude youre restating yourself at this point

you might as well talk to yourself