Message from @sɪᴅɪsɴᴏᴛʜᴇʀᴇ

Discord ID: 534790927135408128


2019-01-15 17:45:05 UTC  

So shouldn’t 70% be even less of a problem

2019-01-15 17:45:07 UTC  

Nobidy denied that

2019-01-15 17:45:18 UTC  

(70% marginal)

2019-01-15 17:45:32 UTC  

What do you mean a problem

2019-01-15 17:45:39 UTC  

I'm just saying theres never been a tax rate higher than 45%

2019-01-15 17:46:12 UTC  

Not an effective tax rate

2019-01-15 17:46:18 UTC  

But a marginal tax rate, yes

2019-01-15 17:46:25 UTC  

Marginal is irrelevant then

2019-01-15 17:46:28 UTC  

Because it's not really paid

2019-01-15 17:46:32 UTC  

or taken

2019-01-15 17:46:37 UTC  

(stole)

2019-01-15 17:46:51 UTC  

It is paid, just not on one’s entire income

2019-01-15 17:47:39 UTC  

And it’s still a greater rate than AOC’s 70%, which is in line with her statement that we’ve had tax rates as high and higher in the past than the ones she’s proposed

2019-01-15 17:47:49 UTC  

Not that I would want a high tax like that

2019-01-15 17:47:49 UTC  

No again

2019-01-15 17:47:50 UTC  

we haven't

2019-01-15 17:47:56 UTC  

It's never been as high as 90%

2019-01-15 17:48:02 UTC  

everyone has used tax avoidance schemes

2019-01-15 17:48:04 UTC  

Marginal rates have been that high

2019-01-15 17:48:10 UTC  

Not effective rates

2019-01-15 17:48:12 UTC  

which is important

2019-01-15 17:48:17 UTC  

or you're just looking at smoke and mirrors

2019-01-15 17:49:00 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/441728840025374731/534791128180850688/image0.png

2019-01-15 17:49:18 UTC  

Then we could say we’ll finance a, say, 40% effective rate with a 70% marginal rate on the rich

2019-01-15 17:49:30 UTC  

You didn't get it dude

2019-01-15 17:49:36 UTC  

they had marginal tax rate at 90% yes

2019-01-15 17:49:42 UTC  

but they were *never paid*

2019-01-15 17:49:47 UTC  

to the point the effective tax rate was 45%

2019-01-15 17:49:57 UTC  

thats what effective tax rate means

2019-01-15 17:54:44 UTC  

I agree

2019-01-15 17:55:03 UTC  

ye thats what I'm saying

2019-01-15 17:55:03 UTC  

I’m saying that AOC’s proposed marginal rate of 70% is significantly less than historical marginal rates up to 94%

2019-01-15 17:55:07 UTC  

yeah

2019-01-15 17:55:23 UTC  

I'm just saying if it were raised to 74% it would harm toe economy

2019-01-15 17:55:26 UTC  

70%

2019-01-15 17:55:47 UTC  

But likely not to the degree that 94% marginal did, which was fairly minimal

2019-01-15 17:55:56 UTC  

0%

2019-01-15 17:56:01 UTC  

Nobody disagreed with that. Like literally nobody.

2019-01-15 17:56:19 UTC  

abolish the govt

2019-01-15 17:56:19 UTC  

Infact income tax should be abolished