Message from @Xinyue

Discord ID: 523899352746295348


2018-12-16 16:24:58 UTC  

so people don't choose which environment they travel into and live in?

2018-12-16 16:24:59 UTC  

the "new people" aren't detatched from the "old ones"

2018-12-16 16:25:31 UTC  

Well, not really. If they have to settle somewhere, that is probably itself driven by pressures - there's not enough food where they used to live in, etc.

2018-12-16 16:26:54 UTC  

the whole point is that the materialist worldview accepts that the objective world of matter exists and is primary, as we all implicitly here seem to agree - whether you like to admit it or not - so you can just as well stop shitting on it

2018-12-16 16:27:21 UTC  

I used to

2018-12-16 16:27:30 UTC  

agree with that

2018-12-16 16:27:33 UTC  

material isn't the primary and marxism is the big gay

2018-12-16 16:27:35 UTC  

Idealism is wholly untenable imo

2018-12-16 16:27:51 UTC  

idk your ideological mumbo jumbo

2018-12-16 16:27:57 UTC  

its not ideological

2018-12-16 16:28:08 UTC  

if u can speak in simple language

2018-12-16 16:28:09 UTC  

i have to stress this - Marxism didn't invent this and isn't the only ideology that subscribes to this

2018-12-16 16:28:12 UTC  

that'll be better

2018-12-16 16:28:19 UTC  

i know that

2018-12-16 16:28:27 UTC  

i just said Capitalism is Materialist

2018-12-16 16:28:33 UTC  

i made that point before you

2018-12-16 16:28:38 UTC  

its not philosophically materialist

2018-12-16 16:28:50 UTC  

I mean it *can be,* but it doesn't have to be

2018-12-16 16:28:55 UTC  

same is actually true of Socialism

2018-12-16 16:28:59 UTC  

you can be idealist and be Socialist

2018-12-16 16:29:02 UTC  

i don't care

2018-12-16 16:29:07 UTC  

._.

2018-12-16 16:29:09 UTC  

as is the case with Strasserism

2018-12-16 16:29:13 UTC  

its idealist and not materialist

2018-12-16 16:29:18 UTC  

but still socialist

2018-12-16 16:29:21 UTC  

what does that mean

2018-12-16 16:29:53 UTC  

it means that it seems to hold the world of ideas primary to the world of matter, at least Strasser considered himself to be idealist and that's what idealism is, so thats what I've got here to work with

2018-12-16 16:30:24 UTC  

i would say Spirituality and your Mental Make Up really do matter

2018-12-16 16:30:40 UTC  

ofc you're playing that game within what you have, which is Material

2018-12-16 16:30:47 UTC  

but it's not like Ideas don't matter

2018-12-16 16:30:47 UTC  

the materialist considers the world of matter primary to the world of ideas. and when I say that capitalism isn't inherently materialist I mean that nothing in capitalist ideology demands that world of matter be primary to world of ideas

2018-12-16 16:31:23 UTC  

@Xinyue do you think it's better to organise a society by building families or without it? do you think that institution can be destroyed?

2018-12-16 16:31:56 UTC  

anything can be destroyed tbh, except matter-energy it seems, but yeah it can be destroyed but I don't think that it should be

2018-12-16 16:32:13 UTC  

now family is an abstract concept

2018-12-16 16:32:36 UTC  

I think family can be quite easily described as a relation of real living beings

2018-12-16 16:32:49 UTC  

a very specific relationship that is

2018-12-16 16:32:52 UTC  

it is a way of organization innit?

2018-12-16 16:33:07 UTC  

Its a way of organization that naturally happens around the parents and their offspring yes

2018-12-16 16:33:15 UTC  

a special kind of bond

2018-12-16 16:33:20 UTC  

due to the nature of the thing they organise around