Message from @MoistBread

Discord ID: 683160784179822610


2020-02-29 03:53:16 UTC  

Sure. I just need some advice on an idea I had at work the other day regarding my Instrument

2020-02-29 03:53:27 UTC  

And thank you

2020-02-29 03:54:01 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678531385123667998/683160015145795629/Carpenter_jesus_irony.jpg

2020-02-29 03:54:09 UTC  

Hit us with da plan

2020-02-29 03:54:36 UTC  

So

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678531385123667998/683160156451897364/Screenshot_2020-02-27-16-35-26.png

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678531385123667998/683160156984705081/Screenshot_2020-02-27-16-36-01.png

2020-02-29 03:54:47 UTC  

These two instruments have the same design and set up right ?

2020-02-29 03:55:03 UTC  

@Uksio What u sayin' 'bout pimps there, Barn?

2020-02-29 03:55:05 UTC  

With he tail peice and bridge

2020-02-29 03:55:20 UTC  

Yes tail piece and bridge

2020-02-29 03:55:24 UTC  

So. I had an idea to do something like this

2020-02-29 03:55:37 UTC  

@MoistBread not necessarily. We don't know their internal layout

2020-02-29 03:55:47 UTC  

Resonance chambers may be totally different

2020-02-29 03:55:51 UTC  

That's true

2020-02-29 03:56:07 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678531385123667998/683160543669911582/20200227_163654.jpg

2020-02-29 03:56:11 UTC  

I was thinking something like this

2020-02-29 03:56:13 UTC  

It's less of a carpentry question, more of a moosic one

2020-02-29 03:56:31 UTC  

Where you can take one set of horns off , and switch for another set

2020-02-29 03:56:39 UTC  

they have cross-brackets and reinforcement "bridges" to hold the string riser

2020-02-29 03:56:45 UTC  

Simply making two into one

2020-02-29 03:56:49 UTC  

And they may be vastly different inside

2020-02-29 03:57:03 UTC  

Well. The lyre is thinner I'll admit

2020-02-29 03:57:10 UTC  

Not to mention that the volume of the resonance chamber/cavity may vary too

2020-02-29 03:57:20 UTC  

True ...

2020-02-29 03:57:35 UTC  

I thought it was a neat idea

2020-02-29 03:58:05 UTC  

Besides... that is not so much carpentry, but musical instrument building

2020-02-29 03:58:40 UTC  

A violin, guitar or a cello maker would be able to tell you much more about that

2020-02-29 03:59:17 UTC  

I was wondering if making a set up like this would affect the structural integrity of the instrument or if I should make another one entirely

2020-02-29 03:59:25 UTC  

Form is not strictly necessary for an instrument - it's the reverb of the resonance chamber that matters

2020-02-29 04:00:17 UTC  

Alrighty. I'll send a few pics of the body tomorrow morning. I have it all finished except for a few designs but the body itself is finished mostly

2020-02-29 04:01:19 UTC  

Well, for structural integrity in any string instrument you need to counteract the string tension without deformation (or without too much of it)

2020-02-29 04:01:43 UTC  

And in some also have a string riser hold that load too

2020-02-29 04:02:01 UTC  

Like it had in the picture of the lyre

2020-02-29 04:02:27 UTC  

Some instruments just have so much wood that string tension and shape don't really matter

2020-02-29 04:02:35 UTC  

Those are essentially overbuilt

2020-02-29 04:03:28 UTC  

But for something as light and thin-walled as cello, the shape has to be what it is for structural integrity

2020-02-29 04:03:52 UTC  

Alright.

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678531385123667998/683162492121251901/20200223_014755.jpg

2020-02-29 04:04:27 UTC  

That's the thickness of the sound box . And it's about 3.5 inches thick

2020-02-29 04:05:10 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678531385123667998/683162811270037560/20200224_164821.jpg

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/678531385123667998/683162811861696580/20200224_164812.jpg

2020-02-29 04:05:14 UTC  

To me it appears to be like two guitar necks joined at the top