Message from @Fitzydog
Discord ID: 488478756391092224
But elections for city council does not translate to the national level
Yea our states mimmic our fed
They dont really here either. They just get all put on the same ballet for ease
And to answer your statement fitz. If states didnt issue the ballpts, then the feds would and it would be mute.
Jeeze, representation without regard to geography would be a nightmare
States prefer to have the control so
And they prolly get funding which helps pay for their own elections held at the same time
Well over here we can traverse the whole country up and down and have time to spare to go on holliday in a single day. Our 'states' are more like municipalities or counties compared to the US.
Yea no geo representation would be insane. Think mass policy being decided by arizona
Fair.
Germany right?
That is what is happening, the majority of the people are in like 4 cities in 2 provinces, every other province barely has a voice in the critical mass.
Netherlands
Ah
Germany is similar, but iirc the people identify regionally far more than nationally
Its almost as if regional govs have more power than the fed internally
Yes, germany is more like the US in that the Bundes (states) have some form of self government that is actually visible in politics.
Your entire country is only 3 times larger than my immediate local region
In the netherlands tehre are secretaries and some staff on province level, but those are appointed by the King, just like Majors are. \
Yeah, but its not less complicated due to it being smaller haha
I'm frustrated enough as it is by not having local representation in my county, for the immediate couple square mile area where I live lol
Well to be honest. Few European countries hold a candle to even our middle sized states
True
Thats a bit extreme
Because all of those 'representatives' are paid, ergo. a representative every couple square miles would be excessively expensive
They don't have to be paid
No one would devote the needed time without pay
Because then they would have jobs as well
My county is 650 sq miles, and they want to put an apartment complex near my house. we have to appeal to a 'council' who will take our opinions into consideration
And? If someone on the other side had the same situation, the same thing would be done. The only exception is cities, but you still simply appeal to the council of the area
Who are generally voted in by the whole area
or districtly
Most of them live on the other side of town, and have no clue what our area is like because they have no reason to come over here
But they are voted in by the county correct?
Not really, sort of
If the seats ever appear on the ballet, and they can be recalled, then they are elected. There isn't a 'sort of'.
Weither they run opposed or not, are ever recalled, or the variation of term limits, is another story.
Yeah, I looked it up. There's 5 seats that get voted on, and everything downstream of that is appointees. Anywho...
In the netherlands decicions like zoning and permits are just government jobs, the politics never touch it unless its to change a local law, none of those positions are voted for. I wish there was accounability for these small time local power mongers with their arcane minutia.
I guess voting on every position is a bit too extreme as well, you would be at the voting booth every day and get no work done hehe
That's why you make everything as local as possible, that way only the people effected in that small area need to discuss and vote on the matter