Message from @Nerthulas

Discord ID: 655933616160899095


2019-12-16 00:41:25 UTC  

asymmetry where there's supposed to be symmetry is a sign of unhealthiness

2019-12-16 00:41:31 UTC  

thus ugly

2019-12-16 00:41:51 UTC  

so symmetry would be objectively beautiful

2019-12-16 00:42:16 UTC  

at the same time, though, randomness and chaos have their own beauty

2019-12-16 00:42:41 UTC  

the explosion of a firework, the billowing of a cloud

2019-12-16 00:42:50 UTC  

yeah, i'm talking about certain facets in nature and living organisms

2019-12-16 00:43:02 UTC  

and saying that unhealthiness means ugly is a very biological take on it like I said

2019-12-16 00:43:21 UTC  

yeah

2019-12-16 00:43:46 UTC  

definitely what makes a healthy human is attractive in its own regard

2019-12-16 00:43:57 UTC  

"healthy" people won't find Sloth from *Goonies* beautiful

2019-12-16 00:44:50 UTC  

there are mathematical ratios, and other things that consistently produce appreciation from humans for evopsych reasons

2019-12-16 00:45:01 UTC  

yeh

2019-12-16 00:45:03 UTC  

this consistency causes some people to claim that beauty is objective

2019-12-16 00:45:05 UTC  

If people disagree on what beauty is isn't that a sign that its subjective?

2019-12-16 00:45:09 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/634415983741763594/655933399491543090/latest.png

2019-12-16 00:45:32 UTC  

eh, its two ways of describing the same thing imo

2019-12-16 00:45:34 UTC  

yeah, but we discard the opinions of unhealthy ppl 🙂

2019-12-16 00:45:40 UTC  

i mean unhealthy

2019-12-16 00:45:42 UTC  

😄

2019-12-16 00:45:44 UTC  

<:monkaS:299267496668692493>

2019-12-16 00:46:00 UTC  

server motto

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/634415983741763594/655933616160899093/unknown.png

2019-12-16 00:46:12 UTC  

Even healthy people have different tastes

2019-12-16 00:46:12 UTC  

<:reeee:640033860067000350>

2019-12-16 00:46:20 UTC  

sure

2019-12-16 00:48:52 UTC  

i can even make an evopsych reason for why fairer skin is more attractive than darker skin

2019-12-16 00:49:12 UTC  

it;s for the same reason that kitchens in high clas restaurants are all white

2019-12-16 00:49:17 UTC  

That's what I thought tbh. I'm not really sure what Kantbot is on about with this "taste is objective" nonsense but I do agree with his opinions on the current state of fantasy fiction.

2019-12-16 00:49:18 UTC  

and operating rooms

2019-12-16 00:49:23 UTC  

its a bit like the claim "words have no meaning because somebody somewhere *could* use a word to mean something totally different than what is understood by its use generally"

2019-12-16 00:49:44 UTC  

you should understand what people mean when they say taste is objective

2019-12-16 00:49:48 UTC  

they aren't strictly wrong

2019-12-16 00:49:53 UTC  

I think someone's taste can be indicative of certain desirable personality traits but this isn't the same as taste being objective.

2019-12-16 00:50:32 UTC  

its objective in the sense that humans consistently recognize that taste, and that taste is based in some evopsych reason

2019-12-16 00:50:48 UTC  

I mean, to me the word objective means its universally true, as in its even true to non humans or robots or aliens.

2019-12-16 00:51:00 UTC  

nothing fulfils that definition of objective

2019-12-16 00:51:29 UTC  

Yeah, I think most things are subjective

2019-12-16 00:51:40 UTC  

no, literally nothing

2019-12-16 00:51:41 UTC  

at least

2019-12-16 00:51:43 UTC  

I can't think of anything

2019-12-16 00:51:52 UTC  

that would fulfil the definition of objective as you put it here

2019-12-16 00:52:06 UTC  

so my standard for 'objectivity' is quite a bit lower