Message from @Nerthulas
Discord ID: 638926951880327179
to use your OWN terminology
it is a falsity in your brain that China was as poor as afria in the year 1900
No one conceded to your smooth brain position @BabygottBach
I mean, late Qing China did seriously fucking suck.
Lol
@Nerthulas I didn't say that. That's your own invention.
I don't give a fuck
they had cities
Stop attributing it to me
the clovis civilization date back to like 13k, there has been evidence of earlier migrations but the evidence isn't as strong @Deleted User
jews control america
that's totally incomparable
to the situation in africa
You don't give a fuck because China utterly blows apart your world view.
Is Bach arguing against both culture and genetics
are you a Jared diamondite?
compared to most of humanity for most of history, Qing China was a wealthy society
Geographic determinism
The fact of the matter is history can not be explained by either IQ or genetics.
@Nerthulas, not the late Qing.
You’re a guns germs and Steelers
13k is plausible, given the differences between natives and modern asians
idk wtf he talking about at this point @fuguer
China had a functioning society in which they had an established civilization
@fuguer, I'm a historical materialist.
He sounds like he took the guns germs and steel pill
And it was and still is socially cohesive
Even though diamonds work is totally discredited by social sciences
Ryan faulk did a nice video on that
That's cuz guns germs and steel, at its best, mirrors Marxist historical materialism.
@Deleted User well, the 13k migrants weren't the same as modern chinese, they just have a shared ancestor
My point is very simple
Guns germs and steel = cuckery
'why did China end up rich and Sub-Saharan Africa end up poor' <:kekboi:417880491182653450>
Why is Africa shit today?
Because of Africans
you are historically illiterate
they are said to be more siberian like following mamoths @Deleted User
If you’re arguing a nations success depends on genetics culture and geographic factors I don’t disagree