Message from @Eternal Entropy

Discord ID: 659844447751766047


2019-12-26 19:39:28 UTC  

..this doesnt seem to have anything to do with my arguments..

2019-12-26 19:39:54 UTC  

well they may be jewish people doing what you claim but they are not jews doing what you claim

2019-12-26 19:40:03 UTC  

they are apostates doing what you claim

2019-12-26 19:40:15 UTC  

polytheism was first.. monotheism comes later

2019-12-26 19:40:23 UTC  

yes I know

2019-12-26 19:40:46 UTC  

doing what I claim?

2019-12-26 19:41:04 UTC  

it's only fair to make the distinction when you claim jews do X when they aren't practicing judaism at all when they are doing Y

2019-12-26 19:41:12 UTC  

before I am spending time that was spending on something else..
What are my claims that you are refuting?

2019-12-26 19:42:09 UTC  

thats an meaningless statement..
what you call judaism is just a label..
There is no single judaism that goes
back to biblical times

2019-12-26 19:42:21 UTC  

judaism is a faded memory of bronze age
mesopotamia

2019-12-26 19:42:22 UTC  

wrong

2019-12-26 19:42:30 UTC  

let me find more false claims

2019-12-26 19:42:34 UTC  

you made a few

2019-12-26 19:42:47 UTC  

everything is written through the lenses of later people
trying to make sense of earlier people

2019-12-26 19:42:56 UTC  

..it is

2019-12-26 19:43:32 UTC  

the bible is not supported by archeological facts..

2019-12-26 19:44:07 UTC  

there is no place to put a bronze age Isreal
and it has to be the bronze age

2019-12-26 19:44:19 UTC  

b-b-b-but... da Bible told me Israel and Judea were large, powerful kingdoms with many architectural wonders!

2019-12-26 19:44:42 UTC  

Just cause some Fedora Tipping Indiana Jones cant find Gods glory out in that desert doesnt make it not true....

2019-12-26 19:45:15 UTC  

So you deny that judism is a gradual evolution
from polytheistic bronze age societies?
You deny that it rewrote its history
and you deny that jews have recreated
their history post-Roman era?

2019-12-26 19:46:15 UTC  

Jesus is based on the archetype
of a young man that you sacrifice for the harvest

No, it's based on the person depicted.
There is no reason to believe otherwise.
Terminology used throughout the bible is written in a manner that is not implicit but comprehensively precise in it's clarity regarding christ as a person and not made up based on an archetype like a JBP lecture.

2019-12-26 19:46:21 UTC  

I am not saying they are not jews..
you can call the entire middle east Jewish..
they are all semitic people

2019-12-26 19:46:56 UTC  

No.. its an archetype.
We have the same stories long before year zero.

2019-12-26 19:47:21 UTC  

Judaism evolved based on each prophet of judaism that came along and added to what judaism is.

2019-12-26 19:47:27 UTC  

There are the dying agricultural gods
in all agricultural societies..
regardless of what gods they have.

2019-12-26 19:47:44 UTC  

Doesnt have to be Gods..
but it takes so long to say.. .character

2019-12-26 19:47:56 UTC  

It was born in and amomg polytheism

2019-12-26 19:48:31 UTC  

..Judaism is shaped by the first shepherds and cattle based society.
Which makes sense given the stories of the bible

2019-12-26 19:48:35 UTC  

'You deny that it rewrote its history'

2019-12-26 19:48:39 UTC  

who?

2019-12-26 19:48:42 UTC  

what?

2019-12-26 19:48:44 UTC  

where?

2019-12-26 19:48:46 UTC  

the jews..

2019-12-26 19:49:09 UTC  

the stories are oldier.. which indicate they are copied

2019-12-26 19:49:25 UTC  

what jews, the ones who worshipped god or polytheists

2019-12-26 19:49:31 UTC  

People copy traditions and costums.
Its traditonal memories dating back to the stone age.

2019-12-26 19:49:34 UTC  

see you don't make distinctions

2019-12-26 19:49:40 UTC  

and leave me in error

2019-12-26 19:49:46 UTC  

We have crosses since the stone age

2019-12-26 19:50:47 UTC  

When the historians want to find proof of when sweden
became Christian..
they use Christian symbols.
But Christian symbols
like the Cross or the fish
are way older than year zero

2019-12-26 19:51:11 UTC  

these are not proofs of yours, they are flimsy assumptions. Taking a cross as a design based on actual crucifixion is very likely