Message from @Phact

Discord ID: 611450977643528192


2019-08-15 06:18:48 UTC  

I like to entertain the idea that there is only one present, but any number of pasts or futures

2019-08-15 06:19:05 UTC  

I remember one past

2019-08-15 06:19:32 UTC  

is existence defined by perception? does the past change when you misremember something?

2019-08-15 06:20:33 UTC  

no, but memory can exist in spite of past reality... it's kind of hard to explain what the practical implications of mulitple pasts would be

2019-08-15 06:29:09 UTC  

like, if the the all-powerful simulation got started just 5 minutes ago, complete with the memories we have of the "past", then those memories would be part of the host history and not real at all

2019-08-15 06:30:22 UTC  

whether we're a simulation or not, any moment in time may as well be the first moment in time, regardless of prior state

2019-08-15 06:33:26 UTC  

But wouldn't the past be implicit in the present? even if it is just simulated

2019-08-15 06:34:38 UTC  

Assuming there is one present.

2019-08-15 06:34:57 UTC  

Or, more to my point, there may be many pasts to a single present

2019-08-15 06:35:24 UTC  

for instance, a single chess board state may have resulted from multiple past play timelines

2019-08-15 06:38:02 UTC  

Chess is an interesting analogy, though I don't know how apt it is, it reduces the importance of momentum in that scenario

2019-08-15 06:38:28 UTC  

if I'm mid jump, I'm either on the way up, or on the way down. You may not be able to tell in a freeze frame, but the next frame will make it obvious

2019-08-15 06:39:08 UTC  

good point, momentum is key

2019-08-15 06:39:28 UTC  

chess fails in this regard

2019-08-15 06:40:44 UTC  

but multiple past moves... two pawns converging on each other from two separate past positions... may cumulate in a single forward move

2019-08-15 06:42:17 UTC  

I'm really stretching here, but if you wanted to move the clock backwards from any state in chess, you could do so with any piece

2019-08-15 06:43:09 UTC  

obviously, the neural pathways of human memory are a hell of a lot more complex

2019-08-15 06:43:28 UTC  

certainly

2019-08-15 06:44:33 UTC  

but... if a static configuration of brain cells can be produced from a multitude of past configurations... how certain are we that there is a single past?

2019-08-15 06:45:04 UTC  

ugh... still didn't exactly explain the momentum issue

2019-08-15 06:47:53 UTC  

I suppose it is theoretically possible, but the particular alignment of any moment in reality, or even one brain configuration, is so infinitely complex that the odds of something happening any different way are so nearly impossible that it's negligible

2019-08-15 06:48:22 UTC  

in an infinitely large universe, sure; but as far as our experience can reach

2019-08-15 06:48:49 UTC  

TBH, this is all simply my attempt to explain Gravity (the movie)

2019-08-15 06:48:53 UTC  

in infinite time and space all rare events are common

2019-08-15 06:49:20 UTC  

^that is what I started to say at the end there

2019-08-15 06:49:57 UTC  

no wait, is Gravity the stupid or smart one... urg

2019-08-15 06:50:11 UTC  

gravity sucks

2019-08-15 06:50:45 UTC  

then... the one that had the black hole and time travel

2019-08-15 06:51:07 UTC  

interstellar

2019-08-15 06:51:07 UTC  

or all space outside of you pushes you towards mass

2019-08-15 06:51:24 UTC  

@Phact yep, Interstellar

2019-08-15 06:51:41 UTC  

looked like they were trying to rescue multiple pasts

2019-08-15 06:53:13 UTC  

@WisdomVendor I think mass may be the end of time

2019-08-15 06:54:06 UTC  

mass is the lowest level of energy

2019-08-15 06:55:52 UTC  

fusion is the lowest level of mass

2019-08-15 06:57:56 UTC  

so were we going to talk about determinism and/or true random in software @WisdomVendor ?

2019-08-15 06:58:24 UTC  

talk or chat? you have a mic?

2019-08-15 06:58:49 UTC  

I can do either

2019-08-15 06:58:57 UTC  

may I call?

2019-08-15 07:01:22 UTC  

go tor it

2019-08-22 00:42:10 UTC  

Roll call plz