Message from @herb

Discord ID: 421204858582990849


2018-03-08 07:12:21 UTC  

you guys are both fucking retards "you're stupid", "NUH UH you're stupid"

2018-03-08 07:12:27 UTC  

peak centrism

2018-03-08 07:12:32 UTC  
2018-03-08 07:12:46 UTC  

no me

2018-03-08 07:13:00 UTC  

@Deleted User tell me what you think

2018-03-08 07:13:04 UTC  

>disagreement

i dont even know what your position is right now

2018-03-08 07:13:19 UTC  

@Brandod what is your political ideology?

2018-03-08 07:13:42 UTC  

@Deleted User you seemed to disagree with what i said earlier

2018-03-08 07:14:07 UTC  

@Deleted Account 81241290a0u523 is that important? good arguments don't rely on the mouths they are from

2018-03-08 07:14:24 UTC  

yeh i said that work that involves surplus value extraction is exploitative

2018-03-08 07:14:25 UTC  

It explains your position more clearly though

2018-03-08 07:14:41 UTC  

@Deleted User i would counter that all work involves that

2018-03-08 07:14:51 UTC  

it by definition doesnt

2018-03-08 07:14:55 UTC  

in every system

2018-03-08 07:15:08 UTC  

can you give me an example?

2018-03-08 07:15:42 UTC  

surplus value extraction is a process in which a capitalist receives money from the excess value that a worker has produced

2018-03-08 07:16:22 UTC  

a worker cant extract surplus value from another worker and this only exists in capitalism

2018-03-08 07:16:54 UTC  

can you explain why it needs to be a capitalist?

2018-03-08 07:17:18 UTC  

@Brandod He means a boss

2018-03-08 07:17:31 UTC  

no a capitalist

2018-03-08 07:17:43 UTC  

capitalist = someone who owns MoP

2018-03-08 07:17:45 UTC  

because thats what happens, workers are not subservient to other workers they are subservient to property owners

2018-03-08 07:17:48 UTC  

you can still have a boss

2018-03-08 07:17:54 UTC  

or a manager

2018-03-08 07:18:10 UTC  

that doesnt have to be the owner

2018-03-08 07:18:17 UTC  

boss of the gym

2018-03-08 07:18:33 UTC  

damn you brock

2018-03-08 07:19:15 UTC  

lets say i have a hammer i lend it to you and you make 10 chairs

2018-03-08 07:19:19 UTC  

i say give me 8

2018-03-08 07:19:24 UTC  

does that sound fair?

2018-03-08 07:19:26 UTC  

@Deleted User but workers are subserviant to other workers and bosses do produce extra value indirectly

2018-03-08 07:19:49 UTC  
2018-03-08 07:19:51 UTC  

do workers sell their labour to other workers or to a capitalist?

2018-03-08 07:19:52 UTC  

a business with good management practices is more efficient that one without

2018-03-08 07:20:12 UTC  

your definition of capitalist seems to be a bit off

2018-03-08 07:20:17 UTC  

you dont need the management to own it

2018-03-08 07:20:18 UTC  

I am a capitalist

2018-03-08 07:20:22 UTC  

yet i am very poor

2018-03-08 07:20:24 UTC  

terminology

2018-03-08 07:20:26 UTC  

do you own mop?

2018-03-08 07:20:32 UTC  

mop?