It worked in Catalonia

Oh they do quite often infact

And resulted in an objective increase in living standards

And productivity lol

Yes illegally.

Calling something illegal doesn't make it wrong

Most people there didn't want to be independent from spain.

What a revolution IS, is questioning the authority of the state

I know.

To then say to question the authority of the state

Is wrong, because the state says its illegal

Guys...it's happening.

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/07/bernie-sanders-slams-defense-contractor-ceo-pay.html

Ifind their reasoning behind the revolution idiotic.

Is circular reasoning

And you're mixing the two events

I nailed it.

The Catalans in the 30s

https://youtu.be/kMY9OfKt4b4

By and large participated in the revolution

As a monolith

No the current event.

They had a vote and they voted to leave by a large majority

The only argument you could make is people just didn't go vote

No they didn't.

But then again maybe that's there

Fault

And yes they did

anarchism doesn't work xd

What the government did was crack down and try to prevent the vote

It happened anyway

That because they couldn't vote in due to fear

They took political prisoners and forced the leaders of Catalonia into exile

And

What?

If the government did that they would probably succeed

The only fear was caused by the Spanish government

No it wasn't.

People were literally having to fight spanish state security forces

Yes it was lol

Not the majority of catalonia