Message from @yung
Discord ID: 431713976787927040
Revisionism is possible through leninism
I mean there are countless ideologies other than Leninism which are completely revisionist
much worse than Leninism
๐๐๐
Anarchism has the smallest amount of opertunity for revisionism
Stalin, makhno> khrushchev
I disagree I think Anarchism has never practically been what it claimed it is
How so
Catalonia wasnโt stateless
it was moneyless though
They were fighting the state
but also parts of China in Mao were moneyless
People in the cnt fai didn't rule over each other
The free territory was stateless and moneyless
No they didnโt but decision making in councils were relegated by cnt-fai officials not voted with consensus
but I donโt condemn it
Well what would have been regulated
material conditions
Okay
What about the free territory
Well there was no money no private property and no state
The used platformism
Goin sleep
I mean I will have to research but I guess
@yung yeah
Its good
Anarchism is just not convincing enough to me
Not convincing enough
and I think that sacrificing a Socialist goal just to prevent hierarchy is weird
No no
In the sense that central authority is needed for defense, for instance
Because capitalism is inherently hierarchical
Yes of course
I know it is ahahaha
Iโm saying
@yung the free territory had the voluntary insurrectionary army
Yes but how much did it last?
They were destroyed by the red army
And you think the red army were the only ones capable of stopping them?