Message from @yung

Discord ID: 431713976787927040


2018-04-06 07:10:32 UTC  

Revisionism is possible through leninism

2018-04-06 07:10:59 UTC  

I mean there are countless ideologies other than Leninism which are completely revisionist

2018-04-06 07:11:06 UTC  

much worse than Leninism

2018-04-06 07:11:28 UTC  

๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘„๐Ÿ‘

2018-04-06 07:12:17 UTC  

Anarchism has the smallest amount of opertunity for revisionism

2018-04-06 07:12:46 UTC  

Stalin, makhno> khrushchev

2018-04-06 07:12:54 UTC  

I disagree I think Anarchism has never practically been what it claimed it is

2018-04-06 07:13:07 UTC  

How so

2018-04-06 07:13:23 UTC  

Catalonia wasnโ€™t stateless

2018-04-06 07:13:35 UTC  

it was moneyless though

2018-04-06 07:13:48 UTC  

They were fighting the state

2018-04-06 07:14:12 UTC  

but also parts of China in Mao were moneyless

2018-04-06 07:14:16 UTC  

People in the cnt fai didn't rule over each other

2018-04-06 07:14:48 UTC  

The free territory was stateless and moneyless

2018-04-06 07:15:15 UTC  

No they didnโ€™t but decision making in councils were relegated by cnt-fai officials not voted with consensus

2018-04-06 07:16:02 UTC  

but I donโ€™t condemn it

2018-04-06 07:16:04 UTC  

Well what would have been regulated

2018-04-06 07:16:10 UTC  

material conditions

2018-04-06 07:16:19 UTC  

Okay

2018-04-06 07:16:45 UTC  

What about the free territory

2018-04-06 07:17:12 UTC  

Not informed enough about it I canโ€™t comment on it

2018-04-06 07:17:36 UTC  

Well there was no money no private property and no state

2018-04-06 07:17:51 UTC  
2018-04-06 07:17:59 UTC  

The used platformism

2018-04-06 07:17:59 UTC  

Goin sleep

2018-04-06 07:18:12 UTC  

I mean I will have to research but I guess

2018-04-06 07:18:19 UTC  

@yung yeah

2018-04-06 07:19:00 UTC  

Its good

2018-04-06 07:19:00 UTC  

Anarchism is just not convincing enough to me

2018-04-06 07:19:20 UTC  

Not convincing enough

2018-04-06 07:19:46 UTC  

and I think that sacrificing a Socialist goal just to prevent hierarchy is weird

2018-04-06 07:19:57 UTC  

No no

2018-04-06 07:20:22 UTC  

In the sense that central authority is needed for defense, for instance

2018-04-06 07:20:26 UTC  

Because capitalism is inherently hierarchical

2018-04-06 07:20:35 UTC  

Yes of course

2018-04-06 07:20:41 UTC  

I know it is ahahaha

2018-04-06 07:20:46 UTC  

Iโ€™m saying

2018-04-06 07:20:52 UTC  

@yung the free territory had the voluntary insurrectionary army

2018-04-06 07:21:03 UTC  

Yes but how much did it last?

2018-04-06 07:21:21 UTC  

They were destroyed by the red army

2018-04-06 07:21:49 UTC  

And you think the red army were the only ones capable of stopping them?