Message from @PugSlugger
Discord ID: 466828640093601803
Explain
It's just an evolution of the feudal system
Hmm not really
Because feudalism doesnt have to be capitalist
@PugSlugger if capitalism is natural, why did siberian villages distribute according to need before the russian imperials came in? This makes no fucking sense
It's just slavery in a different form
Feudalism has more to do with military than economy
Does it?
Landlords aren't a military position
@Deleted User communism is for communes. It is naturally occuring in small communities. Once a community becomes a nation it falls apart
@celeryman2020 they are though lel
Thats the whole point
Yeh look at any small town even in the us
After the dark ages, people formed feudal society because militaries could be raised from a heirarchy
@PugSlugger was revolutionary catalonia a small commune tho? Tens thousands of people
The landlord summons his vassals and sends them to the count then on and on
Capitalism devolves into something damn close
Not really
Was free territory a small commune? It is as big as Norway
There are thematic similarities but its really apples and oranges
They tortured priests to death to prevent dissent
You could say capitalism devolves into communism
Not feudalism
How??
Would you like to know how?
Lol im glad you asked
Capitalism is from England
@PugSlugger yet anarcho-syndicalism was established and the production went up.
They could have done it without killing the clergy tbh
We are talking about economy I thought
Western propoganda is just that communsim/socialism is bad because soviet union was the enemy
Because as businesses get big, they have more money to throw around. Everyone needs money, even politicans. As the corporations band together, they buy out the government slowly gaining more protection against capitalism from naturally eating at their superiority. Normally, when a company gets too big, they dissolve to to market changes and pressure, see the auto industry. When these large industries were failing, they use governmental power to stop their fall.
@PugSlugger also Syrian Kurdistan
Rojava
So capitalism is natural because plutocracy? Trickle down economics?
I'm not sure I'm following how this makes capitalism 1) natural or 2) a good thing
Look up free market communism
Look up worker owned companies
So if I wanted to open a business in socialism, how would that work?
You pay people what they're worth