Message from @Rex Carthaginis
Discord ID: 540901409718272010
It is indeed a fallacy in your case, and I will explain how,
I really don’t care about fallacies, just that these definitions are true. A mixed economy is a mix between socialist intervention and capitalist market forces
You are attempting to use the definition's broadest meaning possible to defend the strictest meaning possible of capitalism.
This is a fallacy, and this is why it's a fallacy. This is disingenuous arguing @sɪᴅɪsɴᴏᴛʜᴇʀᴇ
Capitalism is the free market , socialism is the state of worker ownership
I am a man. Is some twerp came to me and said "My definition of a man is somebody who has six legs" I will laugh at him, since said definition is only held by a minority opinion.
`I really don’t care about fallacies`
Your sentence didn’t make any sense @The Big Oof
Read again
How about instead of making a positive claim, you make the claim AND give reasoning behind it?
Which you won't do
I did
Why is your definition of capitalism valid and not say Marx's who coined the term?
I have above
`Your sentence didn’t make any sense`
`I did`
`I have above`
this entire conversation in a nutshell
why would his definition be correct but mine wouldn’t !
>makes a claim
"Substantiate it"
>"I did"
What type of question is that
Yeah I did gamer Stalin
Many times
```Your sentence didn’t make any sense
I did
I have above```
Where did you explain why my sentence made no sense?
So logically shouldn't he get to define it?
As in literacy , it didn’t make any sense.
Re read what you said
```You are attempting to use the definition's broadest meaning possible to defend the strictest meaning possible of capitalism.
This is a fallacy, and this is why it's a fallacy. This is disingenuous arguing ```
My definition of " @sɪᴅɪsɴᴏᴛʜᴇʀᴇ's mum" is "A person who I am engaged with in a hot sweaty romance".
Someone tell me how this sentence made no sense
Yes the top doesn’t make sense
it indeed does
Broadest meaning possible to defend the strict meaning possible?
Yes
Makes no sense
Broadest meaning of socialism to defend the narrowest meaning of capitalism
There we go
No, you're just a retard, but I'll explain anyway, which is something you'll never do with your claims despite insisting you do.
The broadest meaning in this case is referring to this silly definition of socialism, and the strictest definition is referring to your personal definition of capitalism.
"Socialism is when the government does stuff, therefore, any intervention is not capitalism"
But I didn’t use the broadest or strictest
The width of the definitions were the same
Explain how they are the same.
Socialism is when the state or workers own the mOp