Message from @randomNPCno3
Discord ID: 600539329076658176
it requres homogeninity of thought
and beleif
no wrong think
@randomNPCno3 - Exactly.
People are bitching about my point of socialism being better in theory, and they don't get that theory doesn't fucking matter worth a god damned thing, if pragmatic limitations render the entire argument a moot point.
the problem isn't our understanding it is your data
Socialism is better in theory, but that doesn't mean shit.
Pragmatic limitations render capitalism superior to socialism in all real life situations to date, unless you look at a couple of exceptional coops or communes that usually flame out after a short period because the competence was short lived.
They're more common in Portland Oregon, than anywhere else I can possibly think of. Yet they're trash. Hippies smoking weed and living off the state. 100% of them
if you can't present at least a theoetical design showing how the system could work, how could it work IRL?
side note i just got a book that the author killed himself after publishing
should be spicy
They have real jobs, yes
@Arthur Grayborn I think @Reprehensibletrash has caused some confusion, he's muddying the waters because everyone to the left of him is a commie. I thought I was agreeing with you
@ManAnimal - I already have. Just shift corporate ownership to the state.
State changes all business decisions to account for external factors.
But the actual cost of paying for the rest of the "workers" inflates pretty quickly
so just tear apart and reallocate value someone else made
@randomNPCno3 no, you moron. I said you keep saying it works in theory
Which is hilarious
again, not addressing how to CREATE value
@ManAnimal - Socialism doesn't mandate economic equality.
just allocate other's value
Nothing about socialism says one person can't live in a fucking castle while another person lives in a small one bedroom apartment.
It doesn't just not work in reality, Marx and Engels themselves state it is impossible to get socialism to function. Third fucking page of the communist manifesto
socialsim isn't communism; economy vs governance
The fundamental problem to socialism is government competence.
It's such a glaring problem that anyone who understands a thing about government in practice will laugh their ass off when some NEET suggests that socialism will fix everything.
There's a reason it's viewed as the eternal revolution
@Reprehensibletrash circles can have corners in theory if you never take it off paper
i disagree
because you can't tell me how socialism would work in terms of ITSELF
only can tell me what it is NOT
that isnt' a definition
Jesus, you don't get it.
Exactly like capitalism, but the state owns everything.
That's the ONLY fucking difference.
@randomNPCno3 boundaries and corners aren't the same thing
@ManAnimal socialism is one party control of all revenue streams
not exactly like capitalism
That way the state can readily reallocate resources and account for externalities in business decisions, because in every decision the state eats all the externalities whether positive or negative.
cause it wouldn't be driven by capital interests but by social interests
it would be fundamentally different
people wouldn't have the same motivation to work for a livng