Message from @Death in June

Discord ID: 625925810058035201


2019-09-24 05:20:25 UTC  

Shall I continue?

2019-09-24 05:21:05 UTC  

I don't think that capital concentration should equal political power concentration.

2019-09-24 05:21:15 UTC  

it's not about should

2019-09-24 05:21:20 UTC  

The people can offset the process.

2019-09-24 05:21:40 UTC  

i don't think they can offset it anymore than in the short term without systemic change

2019-09-24 05:21:56 UTC  

If they are conscious enough of the ways Big Business is trying to buy legislation offering it protection.

2019-09-24 05:21:59 UTC  

in the long term political power is always used in service of propertied interests

2019-09-24 05:22:13 UTC  

control over resources is the primary determinant of political power

2019-09-24 05:22:31 UTC  

I don't think so.

2019-09-24 05:22:43 UTC  

the only possible exception would be in situations where such a high degree of formal power is invested in an authority that they can overcome it

2019-09-24 05:22:46 UTC  

The ultimate root of all power is violence.

2019-09-24 05:22:50 UTC  

as in a place like nazi germany

2019-09-24 05:22:56 UTC  

Politically motivated violence at that.

2019-09-24 05:23:30 UTC  

I don't want it to become a Starship Troopers discussion but that's the reality of it.

2019-09-24 05:23:42 UTC  

i mean, that is true, though i think that these things are roots in different ways

2019-09-24 05:24:19 UTC  

And violence is ultimately garnered by the people, not by the property owners.

2019-09-24 05:24:48 UTC  

in general there are acts of violence that are considered to be legitimate and those that aren't, and the legitimacy of violence is generally dictated by those who control resources, but of course it is possible that they can be overthrown if enough people see the violence they sanction as being illegitimate and use their own violence to overturn the system that upholds their rule

2019-09-24 05:24:58 UTC  

If you get the people to use this fundamental capability of theirs against the property owners they just can't compete.

2019-09-24 05:25:27 UTC  

in the long term it only matters insofar as one uses it to affect systemic change though

2019-09-24 05:25:34 UTC  

Now you are getting it @Death in June

2019-09-24 05:25:42 UTC  

if you leave the same power structure intact it will ultimately begin to act according to the same incentives it did before

2019-09-24 05:26:34 UTC  

If there is a large body of ARMED, and I stress the word, citizens out there who are ready to sanction anyone disregarding their values, no amount of property can save you.

2019-09-24 05:26:45 UTC  

As Mao said it:

2019-09-24 05:26:58 UTC  

Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun.

2019-09-24 05:27:44 UTC  

That is why the globalists are so afraid of the AR-15 bunch in the US.

2019-09-24 05:28:04 UTC  

the idea that control over resources is the primary determinant of political power isn't incompatible with the idea that a paradigm of control over resources can be overthrown through extralegal violence

2019-09-24 05:28:38 UTC  

Don't allow corruption to settle in your political institutions and no amount of wealth will be worth the risk of messing in state affairs.

2019-09-24 05:29:05 UTC  

"Don't allow corruption to settle in your political institutions"

2019-09-24 05:29:31 UTC  

It is actually what is going wrong with the West right now.

2019-09-24 05:29:32 UTC  

you may as well tell us to eat the sun

2019-09-24 05:29:39 UTC  

Too much hedonism.

2019-09-24 05:30:19 UTC  

Nope, actually there are many examples of societies in history which managed to get rid of corruption in one way or the other.

2019-09-24 05:30:32 UTC  

It just requires stronger values by the people.

2019-09-24 05:34:10 UTC  

what examples?

2019-09-24 08:44:27 UTC  

@Death in June Did Rome disappeared out of the map?

2019-09-24 08:45:06 UTC  

What about China? Or India? Or Russia? Or even the Maya, the Aztec and the Inca?

2019-09-24 08:45:16 UTC  

No, they didn't.

2019-09-24 08:46:01 UTC  

They had their heyday, than some nasty things happened to them, and then, they had to readjust and make do with whatever they had but on a smaller scale.

2019-09-24 08:48:29 UTC  

Societies can manage hedonism if they are ale to adjust themselves to the newer circumstances, it just will take them some efforts and real actual energy BY the people themselves FOR the people themselves to actually do it.

2019-09-24 08:49:29 UTC  

Currently may be the US is undergoing such a period with the rise of the New Right and the growing disgust with its leadership.

2019-09-24 08:50:36 UTC  

I really don't know how far would it get but the thing is the US can save themselves if they want to and in the process create an example for the whole world to follow.