Message from @Deleted User
Discord ID: 339334691679240193
the Paris Commune did not rule France
Because it failed due to starvation because Paris couldn't produce enough food to sustain itself.
there was a national government with an army, which invaded a Commune which was against the government
most if not all cities have that attribute
you're really saying very little
I would even say many countries have that attribute
Yeah, you couldn't grow enough food in paris to feed everyone in paris.
if countries didn't import food, lots of people would starve
that's regardless of economic system
Most cities have small communes that still benefit from the capital built by those outside the commune
The idea of a commune couldn't exist without piggybacking off of the bourgeoisie
The Paris Commune failed because of infighting, lack of food, destroyed ifrastructure, rampant desease and poor management.
how about the entirity of Europe being against it?
You mean like Germany?
and France
and even though they weren't involved, the other powers as well
He meant the 3rd reich
Russia, Britain, Austria-Hungary, etc.
Those powers had nothing to do with the Paris Commune.
because it was destroyed too quickly
It failed because none of the people involved were actually proletariat
they were still against it because the success of the Paris Commune would be a challenge to those in power
that's why everyone invaded the Soviet Union during its formation as well
Except that never happened, ever.
look at how long the U.S. was at war with Vietnam
or the embargo of Cuba
Now you're all over the place.
the success of another system is a challenge to those in power
Who invaded the USSR in 1922?
jews did
jews did
many countries did
for example the U.S.
The US didn't invade the RSFSR
The point is, that the Paris Commune FAILED by its own hand.
but look at how many countries
but really it was the crown and tresury aka church gave order to redshields to fund both sides
really now?