Message from @Deleted User

Discord ID: 596353161770434560


2019-07-04 14:50:39 UTC  

Maybe you're *just not* Communist.

2019-07-04 14:50:52 UTC  

implying

2019-07-04 14:51:11 UTC  

you assume because i have expressed critizism 😄

2019-07-04 14:51:15 UTC  

Class relates to a definite and largely fixed relationship to the means of production which is not consciously-enforced.

2019-07-04 14:51:20 UTC  

>this line again

2019-07-04 14:51:21 UTC  

so short sighted and narrowminded

2019-07-04 14:51:55 UTC  

No, you are recycling an argument which is antithetical to Communist argumentation because the point of Communism is to abolish class society *and keep on abolishing it*.

2019-07-04 14:52:11 UTC  

class also related to the ability to produce

2019-07-04 14:52:21 UTC  

including producing controll over something

2019-07-04 14:52:49 UTC  

byou cant abolish classes

2019-07-04 14:52:56 UTC  

you need specializations

2019-07-04 14:53:09 UTC  

And people don't have to stick with particular specialisations.

2019-07-04 14:53:10 UTC  

and you have them in the form of skills and atributes of indivuals

2019-07-04 14:53:22 UTC  

to destroy class you need to destroy mankind

2019-07-04 14:53:35 UTC  

whit in hiostory has been attempted several times by communism

2019-07-04 14:53:35 UTC  

This reeks of the human nature argument.

2019-07-04 14:53:47 UTC  

or at least the movements that call themself such

2019-07-04 14:54:13 UTC  

>he calls himself a Communist when he assumes that Communism is literally impossible apart from his which respects classes

2019-07-04 14:54:22 UTC  

the reason why ppl do stick with specilization is because they cant do something else or they are just really good at that

2019-07-04 14:54:31 UTC  

And what do you think learning is?

2019-07-04 14:54:33 UTC  

ppl are creatures of habit and this is their nature

2019-07-04 14:55:02 UTC  

You talk as if this 'nature' is immutable and unchangeable.

2019-07-04 14:55:10 UTC  

you think you can learn intelect?

2019-07-04 14:55:36 UTC  

You think you cannot learn to change it?

2019-07-04 14:55:42 UTC  

nope,

2019-07-04 14:55:47 UTC  

you can only condition it

2019-07-04 14:56:03 UTC  

>muh biological determinism

2019-07-04 14:56:20 UTC  

Muh facts, read em and weep, . you stil not making an argument

2019-07-04 14:56:25 UTC  

Already addressed before. What do you think that biological procedures are supposed to do?

2019-07-04 14:56:43 UTC  

We have gene therapies, we have surgeries, we have so many things and we are improving them at the direction of capital.

2019-07-04 14:56:43 UTC  

what biological procedures are you talking about ?

2019-07-04 14:56:57 UTC  

I already said this many of times TL DR

2019-07-04 14:57:07 UTC  

it means to long did not read

2019-07-04 14:57:08 UTC  

That we supposedly cannot change these things is purely to do with our present incompetence.

2019-07-04 14:57:21 UTC  

>tl;dr

2019-07-04 14:57:46 UTC  

So assume no one reads it , shouldnt be to hard for you. that when you write more then 2 paragraphs

2019-07-04 14:58:05 UTC  

You cant change the biological potential of a being

2019-07-04 14:58:17 UTC  

Not even with prosthetics?

2019-07-04 14:58:21 UTC  

Or *vitamins*?

2019-07-04 14:58:28 UTC  

**Or gene therapy?**