Message from @Lucas 4313
Discord ID: 417128003030614016
this guy gets it
My problem with Stalinism (or Vanguardism, really) is the fact that revisionists almost immediately came in after Stalin's death; too much power is placed in one group when it should be placed on the masses as a whole (Platformism)
and i guess the makhnovians were also counter-revolutionaries.
the hungarians were counter-revolutionaries.
everyone i don't like is a counter-revolutionary
makhno literally was and so were the hungarians they literally fought the red army
but on rushack
Also the Anarchist revolution in Spain were also purging themselves of counter-revolutionaries
the anarchist were the counter revolutionaries
they broke away
Look up anything about the Spanish Civil War that focuses on the Anarchists and you never hear the end of "muh churches", "muh dead nuns", "muh landowners"
they fought for the liberation of the proletariat, but with different approaches, but i guess that constitutes being counter-revolutionary.
and i guess capitulating to the state makes you a revolutionary
Didn't Lenin personally have no real problem with Makhno?
makhno is the most respectable anarchist, but I still strongly disagree with him and he does not deserve any power
trotsky killed makhnovia, in all honesty
Lenin did
Trotsky convinced him he was a threat though but told him he was useful for now
then he fucking killed him lol
in the tankies' collective mindset, capitulating to the state is REVOLUTIONARY
they were fighting a civil war
with many factions
Can we talk about Holodomor yet?
and is a threat
Without Makhno, Ukraine would have probably had a more prominent counter-revolutionary movement tbh
ukraine alone could not stand to the red army no matter which way you put it
not much would change with or without the anarchist
they lose in every situation
because EVERYONE is trying to kill them.
BIG SURPRISE
yeah
How might you explain the failure of ML movements later in the 20th century?
NATO and modern technology
you couldnt just fly over to Russia and send tons of equipment in
things were slower
honestly, that
nato is a bunch of cocksuckers
atleast we can agree on that
nato triple gay
if holodomor was about the kulaks, i don't exactly have sympathy for them. but maybe killing was going to far. simply expropriating the expropriators (maybe exiling them) and stopping there would have been nicer
give that land to the people and not the state
oh, so it wasn't just about the kulaks.
FOR SHAME
well, on the bright side, we won't ever have to worry about tankies again
i can honestly thank the capis for that one