Message from @RandomDiscordAccount
Discord ID: 638621667630776321
Your axiomatic assertion that agency fundamentally determines reality is flawed.
Civilization itself has only existed for about 7000 years
just if you have writing as requirement but sedentary societies have existed for 13,000 @Fidel Castro
Most of what we do and are is based upon the decisions and actions of the past. You cant just give civilization to people who haven't gone through the proper selective pressures yet.
I haven't heard of any civilization that old
the natufians descend from sedentary people who existed prior to the invention of agriculture
@Fidel Castro then youre just uneducated and ignorant
@Fidel Castro bro the bible is a meme
name one civilization existing before 5000 BC
there you go
@Fidel Castro please understand that sedentary society is far older than you think
hmmm... seems like just tribes with some small technology
it existed since the begining of the Holocene
they were the first agriculturalist with stone houses, ovens, bakeries, cities, water management and so on
both ancient egyptions and minoans greeks descend from the natufians @Fidel Castro
ok i concede i was wrong
theyre literally the ones who spread the afro-Asiatic language
basically all of north and east africa are natufian colonies
but then how does this explain Native American civilization
aztecs
aztecs were trash but what about em?
inca were better in everyway
but why are you bringing 'em up?
they couldn't have been natufian
No one said all civilisation is natufian
Just all "African" civilisation
no one claimed they were but they are a northern Eurasian mix
yeah, exactly ^
They may as well have Independently arose because they had simmilar selective pressures applied to them
wouldn't the natufian genes be diluted so much not to matter after a certain point
even if supposedly they were so different
@Fidel Castro the majority of north african heritage is from the natufians
like let me be clear here
That's a pretty hefty claim
source?
all modern west eurasians descend from a few genetically cohesive groups who coloinized the majority of west Eurasia
lol sure literally look at the wiki link i already gave you
but sure, ill give you more