Message from @ebowden

Discord ID: 405922465802354688


2018-01-25 03:01:17 UTC  

It's a combination of the altered genetic strands of the parents combined with the human DNA trying to reassert itself.

2018-01-25 03:01:34 UTC  

They did not invent this tech. They merely co opted it.

2018-01-25 03:02:22 UTC  

They aren't a group of renegade scientists. They're a religious cult.

2018-01-25 03:02:49 UTC  

They're whole history is a comedic bunch of fail.

2018-01-25 03:03:21 UTC  

Oh forgot to mention, they are also based a bit on the Free Man on the Land Movement.

2018-01-25 03:03:38 UTC  

It's not that it sounds like it's written ABOUT people who know little about biology.

2018-01-25 03:03:57 UTC  

It sounds like it's written BY someone who knows little about biology.

2018-01-25 03:04:40 UTC  

Their founder (now deceased) tried to argue that he could not be arrested and prosceuted for a crime because his alterations meant he wasn't human.

2018-01-25 03:05:39 UTC  

Not the biggest expert on biology I've got to admit. So that is a fair cop. However, in my defense this was written in 2005 and our knowledge of how we'd even go about altering the human genome was a bit less.

2018-01-25 03:06:27 UTC  

"Not the biggest expert on biology"
Understatement of the decade.

2018-01-25 03:07:12 UTC  

Also, this:

2018-01-25 03:07:21 UTC  

"It's a combination of the altered genetic strands of the parents combined with the human DNA trying to reassert itself."

2018-01-25 03:07:35 UTC  

In genetics, we call that "nonsense".

2018-01-25 03:08:01 UTC  

Not a "nonsense mutation", just nonsense.

2018-01-25 03:08:42 UTC  

The idea was that similar to how we genetically modify things now it was introduced to the body piggybacked on a viral agent (which was my understanding of how that worked at the time). That works good for plants, but not as well on something as complex as a human.

2018-01-25 03:09:25 UTC  

Well, it works well when there are far fewer cells to get the genetic material in.

2018-01-25 03:09:32 UTC  

As in the case of embryos.

2018-01-25 03:09:47 UTC  

Due to an arbitrary tech roadblock I created you couldn't use these techniques to create new life from stratch. Only alter an already existing structure.

2018-01-25 03:10:29 UTC  

Right, that's why in the story they have essentially three variants basted on when the alterations were introduced.

2018-01-25 03:10:34 UTC  

Well, altering an extisting structure would be how any sensible person would do it anyway.

2018-01-25 03:10:57 UTC  

Yes, THAT bit I liked.

2018-01-25 03:12:39 UTC  

Then I got to the nonsensical malformations, and worse yet, your description of the mechanism that brought them about.

2018-01-25 03:14:39 UTC  

Well I can explain my line of reasoning, and you can tell me how I am wrong.

2018-01-25 03:15:18 UTC  

It's just a genome, it has no intelligence.

2018-01-25 03:15:38 UTC  

Well, yes. Of course.

2018-01-25 03:16:03 UTC  

There won't be a battle between the wild type and non-wild type parts.

2018-01-25 03:16:11 UTC  

It doesn't work like that.

2018-01-25 03:16:36 UTC  

Fair point.

2018-01-25 03:16:44 UTC  

So here's how my reasoning went.

2018-01-25 03:20:35 UTC  

So this tech, when the recrants stole it, was still in a very early stages. These stories take place not that far in the future. So the way it alters DNA is crude, slapdash. In some cases fragments of the human DNA are still left behind.

2018-01-25 03:21:15 UTC  

Now when I was saying the human DNA is reasserting itself I don't mean that as literally as I think you are taking it. I will get to that.

2018-01-25 03:24:43 UTC  

As I said the DNA alteration is done via a viral agent. One of the breakthroughs that makes this possible is the viral agent is self replicating in itself, and so once introduced into the body it is perpetual. It coexists wit the body theoretically symbiotically.

2018-01-25 03:25:01 UTC  

Wat

2018-01-25 03:25:19 UTC  

Is it even integrated into the genome?

2018-01-25 03:25:26 UTC  

Both.

2018-01-25 03:26:21 UTC  

Ok I can see how this is confusing.

2018-01-25 03:26:27 UTC  

It isn't now.

2018-01-25 03:26:40 UTC  

Like I said not a biologist. Thanks for helping me sort this out.

2018-01-25 03:27:11 UTC  

I guess stricly speaking it might not.

2018-01-25 03:27:16 UTC  

So, how does this not spread and turn a shitload of people's babies into furries?

2018-01-25 03:28:08 UTC  

Also, the self-replicating stuff is not in the least bit necessary for when they modify embryos.