Message from @ChampionEmperor

Discord ID: 513091093231960101


2018-11-16 02:57:15 UTC  

Maybe, it depends on the issue

2018-11-16 02:57:49 UTC  

I reject democracy, while at the same time I believe in a form of meritocracy

2018-11-16 02:59:03 UTC  

Freedom is ideal under my standards

2018-11-16 02:59:15 UTC  

democracy at the local level

2018-11-16 12:49:41 UTC  

aristocracy in the highest form is meritocracy

2018-11-16 13:13:22 UTC  

Lol

2018-11-16 13:26:47 UTC  

You're fantastic at rebuttal, enjoyed this conversation. Lots of salient points to consider.

2018-11-16 14:21:09 UTC  

so aristocracy rises and attains a position and can lose said position and others can gain said position through some meritocratic non destructive method? If so that would be to some degree meritocratic given everyone had the chance to attain said position. I myself see the need for some form of symbolic aristocracy or such a class in society, much like a warrior class, however they cannot be barred to 99% of society propting merit. (mostly for the sake of making and creating a model)

2018-11-16 16:27:46 UTC  

Aristocrats do not represent the common interest, therefore cannot help but extract from it to suit their own interests

2018-11-16 16:28:23 UTC  

Apologetics to oligarchic clusters is laughable

2018-11-16 16:30:57 UTC  

There is nothing meritocratic or geniocratic about aristocracies

2018-11-16 16:35:56 UTC  

The social relation to production that this caste idea presents just offers a distinct regression backwards into history during the times of the small peasantry

2018-11-16 16:38:14 UTC  

Aristocracy based on merit does not exist because the virtue of inheritance of this caste power does not create geniocracy

2018-11-16 16:42:53 UTC  

Apologetics to the concentration of wealth and power for a quality that is not perpetuated is wrong

2018-11-16 19:48:44 UTC  

Aristocrats would actually care about principles while common people represent their own interests. Leaving decision to common people is like deciding Science based on voting by plebs

2018-11-16 20:38:19 UTC  

The entire history of aristocracy dilutes that silly claim until all that is left is shit water

2018-11-16 20:39:27 UTC  

For all of time aristocracies held the power and wealth and squandered it away from any lower caste peoples

2018-11-16 20:39:53 UTC  

Not very geniocratic

2018-11-16 20:40:21 UTC  

aristocracy is eh IF they are politically educated and know how to run a country

2018-11-16 20:40:29 UTC  

and have the people's interest in mind as well

2018-11-16 20:40:49 UTC  

but eventually due to them not being elected, rather born into it

2018-11-16 20:41:00 UTC  

It's like trying to say companies in a market are held honest because of consumer input

2018-11-16 20:41:17 UTC  

you get assholes who only care about the elites and themselves, they will only vote to keep the elites elite and the poor poor

2018-11-16 20:42:22 UTC  

@ChampionEmperor yeah it's almost like for all of time the privileged class and their bourgeois right perpetuates their positions for the interests of themselves

2018-11-16 20:42:31 UTC  

And not the principles of society

2018-11-16 20:46:52 UTC  

nope

2018-11-16 20:47:14 UTC  

I'm talking about an aristocratic system where they hold political power such as the nobles did

2018-11-16 20:47:41 UTC  

All systems with such power dynamic

2018-11-16 20:47:49 UTC  

I'm not talking about people with money, albeit that they do hold political influence with money to campaigns, I'm talking about significant power like a vote

2018-11-16 20:48:07 UTC  

I wasn't necessarily talking money

2018-11-16 20:48:25 UTC  

The power dynamic of politics is inseparable from the power dynamic of wealth

2018-11-16 20:52:37 UTC  

hmm

2018-11-16 20:52:45 UTC  

I see where you're coming from

2018-11-16 20:53:28 UTC  

I can agree to an extent however I don't find it so similar that it' is comparable to an aristocracy

2018-11-16 20:53:34 UTC  

like nobles

2018-11-17 00:10:09 UTC  

no its the same

2018-11-17 00:27:32 UTC  

The entire history of how Marx viewed it. The free market and trade liberalisation lobby by aristocrats benefitted poor people immensely.

2018-11-17 00:32:35 UTC  

No it benefitted merchants and pushed them into the dominant sphere of the economy

2018-11-17 00:37:08 UTC  

Yes and it raised living standards of poor which can be shown by increase in median GDP per capita

2018-11-17 01:16:20 UTC  

the concept of GDP how we know it didnt come about until after world war 1

2018-11-17 01:17:06 UTC  

long long long after private money making engendered capitalism