Message from @Reb Trump

Discord ID: 529436560790388745


2018-12-31 23:07:01 UTC  

should I stop to identify as being white

2018-12-31 23:07:08 UTC  

will you consider that a win or a loss?

2018-12-31 23:07:29 UTC  

So, then what do you say about genetic tests being able to tell Ashkenazim apart from Europeans?

2018-12-31 23:07:54 UTC  

the simple answer is that people don't identify by genetic tests

2018-12-31 23:08:09 UTC  

Well, yeah, that goes back to your wondering about Tejanos

2018-12-31 23:08:28 UTC  

I've asked my friends about this

2018-12-31 23:08:34 UTC  

and this is how it goes each time

2018-12-31 23:08:42 UTC  

you'll ask if they're white

2018-12-31 23:08:49 UTC  

you'll get an instant yes

2018-12-31 23:08:55 UTC  

then you'll bering up genetics

2018-12-31 23:09:02 UTC  

and they'll start thinking about it

2018-12-31 23:09:30 UTC  

there is a genetic component to race

2018-12-31 23:09:36 UTC  

and a social one

2018-12-31 23:09:45 UTC  

and an interaction variables

2018-12-31 23:09:58 UTC  

the interaction variable is how society sees you

2018-12-31 23:10:17 UTC  

and they base it off phenotype, which is dictated by genetics

2018-12-31 23:10:37 UTC  

you can cite all the race science in the world

2018-12-31 23:10:59 UTC  

but choosing where to draw the line between caucasian whites and caucasian nonwhites is social

2018-12-31 23:11:29 UTC  

genetics don't abide by european borders , and neither does phenotype

2018-12-31 23:11:43 UTC  

I identify by what people see me as

2018-12-31 23:11:52 UTC  

I'm ultimately indifferent to the broader category

2018-12-31 23:11:58 UTC  

Yeah, I can agree with what you're saying to some degree

2018-12-31 23:11:59 UTC  

but because everyone has always seen me as white

2018-12-31 23:12:05 UTC  

I see myself as white

2018-12-31 23:12:15 UTC  

Are you religiously Jewish as well?

2018-12-31 23:12:20 UTC  

i'm secular

2018-12-31 23:12:43 UTC  

So, I suppose marrying a non-Jew is not out of the question then for you

2018-12-31 23:12:52 UTC  

or is it

2018-12-31 23:12:55 UTC  

sure, but I'd prefer a jew

2018-12-31 23:14:56 UTC  

if you were to retrain society to identify jews as nonwhite, it would have funny consequences

2018-12-31 23:15:06 UTC  

such as

2018-12-31 23:15:23 UTC  

other whites who could pass as jews would then stop being seen as white

2018-12-31 23:15:31 UTC  

because they now resemble a nonwhite group

2018-12-31 23:15:49 UTC  

and

2018-12-31 23:15:59 UTC  

jews could get affirmative action

2018-12-31 23:16:05 UTC  

which would be hilarious

2018-12-31 23:16:12 UTC  

I won't complain, but I doubt you'd want that

2018-12-31 23:16:51 UTC  

At the point that Jews are considered non-white, I doubt there'd be much favor for them

2018-12-31 23:17:23 UTC  

you're assuming that once society bends to one of your ideas about jews, they'd bend to the rest

2018-12-31 23:17:37 UTC  

fair

2018-12-31 23:18:30 UTC  

now tell me, what do you want to see happen?