Message from @Darkstar

Discord ID: 500200073490071553


2018-10-12 06:52:35 UTC  

They were not pragmatists either

2018-10-12 06:52:41 UTC  

Hitler fundamentally rejects pragmatism

2018-10-12 06:52:49 UTC  

people are people regardless of ideology, I'm sure Lenin thought that Stalin was an "idealistic Marxist" that "doesn't reject global revolution."

2018-10-12 06:53:10 UTC  

even with completely different standards you will end up with successors who go back on their previous behavior

2018-10-12 06:53:34 UTC  

ok, but if you take that argument to its logical conclusion, in the plutocratic shadow elite version the "people who are people" who become tyrants through the weaknesses of capitalist democracies are harder to then overthrow

2018-10-12 06:53:34 UTC  

Power corrupts the very minute it’s given

2018-10-12 06:53:48 UTC  

which means your system in which corruption is inevitable anyways because of this maxim leads to even greater danger than mine

2018-10-12 06:53:52 UTC  

the checks and balances built into the system exist to prevent that

2018-10-12 06:53:55 UTC  

since unlike your system we might have one tyrant

2018-10-12 06:54:01 UTC  

the problem is that with Führerprinzip you don't have them

2018-10-12 06:54:04 UTC  

whereas you may have 200 billionaire tyrants

2018-10-12 06:54:21 UTC  

checks and balances have failed

2018-10-12 06:54:27 UTC  

unless you're arguing that America is not a plutocracy

2018-10-12 06:54:52 UTC  

I don't think we're a plutocracy

2018-10-12 06:54:55 UTC  

Can we check and balance niggers

2018-10-12 06:55:31 UTC  

ok then explain why super pacs are allowed?

2018-10-12 06:56:21 UTC  

citizens united

2018-10-12 06:56:23 UTC  

essentially infinite lobbying enacted

2018-10-12 06:56:25 UTC  

super pacs are regulated

2018-10-12 06:56:30 UTC  

not really

2018-10-12 06:56:30 UTC  

what are super pacs?

2018-10-12 06:56:34 UTC  

not as much as they should be but they are

2018-10-12 06:56:36 UTC  

the regulations for who donates are pretty shitty

2018-10-12 06:56:42 UTC  

foreigners can donate too btw

2018-10-12 06:56:48 UTC  

as long as they do it through a US corporate entity

2018-10-12 06:57:19 UTC  

look I don't want to go into a tangent proving America is a plutocracy, it is but that would be a waste of time

2018-10-12 06:57:30 UTC  

super pacs prove it outright imo

2018-10-12 06:57:38 UTC  

but there's other points to that

2018-10-12 06:58:09 UTC  

yeah american divisions of foreign companies can contribute to pacs

2018-10-12 06:58:23 UTC  

Anyways, your argument that human nature cannot handle power intrinsically that undermines your position.

2018-10-12 06:58:39 UTC  

Even if the US was not a plutocracy (which it is) it would still in your mind deteriorate into one

2018-10-12 06:58:50 UTC  

because of the corruption you stated that people have when dealing with power

2018-10-12 06:59:02 UTC  

so your presupposition leads to negating your view that capitalist democracy is a good system

2018-10-12 06:59:16 UTC  

no, because the entire system is designed around that belief

2018-10-12 06:59:20 UTC  

(going to refer to it as cap dem rep for short now)

2018-10-12 06:59:47 UTC  

the whole system of government is designed to check ambition with ambition and check power with power

2018-10-12 06:59:48 UTC  

yes, and my point is, because you diversify your tyrants into 2000, by your own logic now you have 2000 psychopaths to contend with

2018-10-12 06:59:53 UTC  

as opposed to 1 in an authoritarian system

2018-10-12 07:00:10 UTC  

their power is limited to prevent them from becoming tyrants

2018-10-12 07:00:23 UTC  

and it's not just 1 guy in an authoritarian system

2018-10-12 07:00:27 UTC  

their power is not limited, because capitalist societies have all degraded into plutocracies