Message from @Kaznith

Discord ID: 683892401982537785


2020-03-02 04:06:52 UTC  

My apartment is small and my dryer introduces humidity levels higher than FL

2020-03-02 04:07:55 UTC  

But I fucking love Florida

If you gave me a fishing pole I could survive there

2020-03-02 04:08:29 UTC  

My dad is from Key West

2020-03-02 04:08:43 UTC  

Used to spend 2 months there every summer

2020-03-02 04:16:15 UTC  

hey, i could use some advice from someone: i have a weak question for an academic paper that i need to make stronger

2020-03-02 04:16:21 UTC  

it's for a forensic science course, i needed to choose a topic in the field to get deeper in, i chose forensic anthropology because that's what i want to end up doing eventually

2020-03-02 04:16:31 UTC  

well, my question in part A was weak and as a consequence i'm having problems arguing against it for a counter-point

2020-03-02 04:16:45 UTC  

"Can forensic anthropology be utilized scientifically to determine if a mass grave is the site of a human rights violation?" is my question

2020-03-02 04:18:33 UTC  

the only arguments i can think of making against it are religious and cultural opposition to exhumation of bodies, preventing the examination of corpses for perimortem causes

2020-03-02 04:19:01 UTC  

also political, as turkey is doing to hide armenian genocide mass graves

2020-03-02 04:19:36 UTC  

my question is too weak, though. i'm having difficulty thinking of a way to narrow it down to something more divisive

2020-03-02 04:20:37 UTC  

what would be the environmental impact of a mass grave? i know our bodies decompose well off but in terms of just tossing a few thousand into one area

2020-03-02 04:20:45 UTC  

So you can still better your question?

2020-03-02 04:20:53 UTC  

that can't be that good for an ecosystem surely right?

2020-03-02 04:21:09 UTC  

@rona man depends how deep i guess

2020-03-02 04:21:49 UTC  

well, there are syrians who built farms over mass graves from the ottoman empire, so it's not that bad

2020-03-02 04:22:07 UTC  

and serbians grew pine trees over some mass graves to cover them up

2020-03-02 04:22:59 UTC  

societal impact would be deep for most people i'd imagine, take a look at a picture of a concentration camp mass grave and dread more often than not sets in

2020-03-02 04:23:16 UTC  

my problem is with my question, it's hard to argue against an established science

2020-03-02 04:23:43 UTC  

"CAN it be utilized scientifically to determine..." is my issue

2020-03-02 04:24:14 UTC  

it obviously can because it has; mass graves are very different depending on the circumstances, like a plague grave versus a genocide grave

2020-03-02 04:24:30 UTC  

i need a better question to analyze

2020-03-02 04:26:49 UTC  

there are ethical concerns in anthropology about false findings, and forensic science, about doctored results i guess

2020-03-02 04:28:06 UTC  

ask the same question differently

2020-03-02 04:28:16 UTC  

"can" is redundant

2020-03-02 04:28:41 UTC  

would "is" be better?

2020-03-02 04:28:48 UTC  

the science in practice works, its almost like

2020-03-02 04:29:01 UTC  

youre questioning its credibility

2020-03-02 04:29:07 UTC  

if you get what im saying

2020-03-02 04:29:18 UTC  

"CAN it be utilized" it can and it has

2020-03-02 04:29:59 UTC  

Ask as if you're presenting forensic anthropology to an audience that doesn't know what it is

2020-03-02 04:30:23 UTC  

to be fair, a lot of them probably don't.

2020-03-02 04:30:35 UTC  

for me

2020-03-02 04:30:58 UTC  

the word "can" questions if something is able to do something

2020-03-02 04:31:10 UTC  

its like if you were about to pay for food and the cashier asks

2020-03-02 04:31:18 UTC  

"are you sure you can pay that"

2020-03-02 04:31:39 UTC  

so should i ask "Is forensic anthropology utilized scientifically to determine if a mass grave is the site of a human rights violation?"

2020-03-02 04:31:56 UTC  

I'd say more like

2020-03-02 04:31:57 UTC  

That's a similar argument but carries a lot different weight

2020-03-02 04:32:11 UTC  

and the cashier asks "are you sure I can ingest your meaty urethrastick"

2020-03-02 04:32:15 UTC  

and you say yes