If you acknowledge Muslims in the past contributed greatly to our society today, then you provide reason to believe that Muslims today can contribute greatly to society as well

And my experience is that such people exist

And America is greater for them

I don't think you're listening to my points

anecdotal evidence is irrelevant

your points are against the religion itself

You're points are only covering Islam as an overarching entity and not down to the individual, which is what Yuri is talking about.

which none of us are advocating for

my point is, that is how Muslims behave when they are the majority

and you aren't acknowledging her points

or well, weren't

There's definitely more nuance there.

yes, anecdotally individual Muslims have contributed to society, big fucking deal

when Muslims are the majority, they make treat women as second class citizens, kill gays, etc. etc

you guys think if we just let them come and just be nice everything will be cool

JUST BE NICE

lol.

the issue is with the leadership there

i kinda agree tbh

if muslims are a majority there is 70% chance that there would radical islamic revolt

This is what I joined the conversation to counter: "I don't know why I'd want to go to every single Muslim and see if they commit a crime or not when it'd just be easier to remove all of them and it'd cause like no harm to the country"

The culture also plays a factor to be fair, which is why people coming to the US should assimilate at least to an extent.

yes, integration is key

Muslims should be deported

and they do get assimilated. not opinion, based on fact.

I'm not saying we shouldn't limit immigration, but to argue that we should get rid of what we have is reprehensible

look at sweden

Then quasi argued we don't need Muslim physicians when i know that we do.

we don't need specifically Muslim physicians

a physician can be non barbarian and be just as good

Right, nobodies saying bring in only Muslim physicians though

I totally endorse integration

Just don't bar Muslims specifically because they're Muslim.

The Muslims I have interacted with are intrgrating/have integrated

Hell, I've sipped wine with Muslim friends 🥂

so qwasi, you would prefer a shortage of physicians over physicians with a different set of beliefs?

this is why anecdotal evidence is useless though

your experience with a handful of people is meaningless

i posted a study showing that integration is happening

and they do get assimilated

lol