Message from @Pelth

Discord ID: 624065975339319307


2019-09-19 02:11:08 UTC  

forced public executions, eveyone has to watch

2019-09-19 02:11:29 UTC  

@Pelth we have data on this. the black american slaves had better diets, less work horus, better literacy rates, more spending money and so on than eastern european serfs did even in the 1700s, let alone the misery and hellscape of 1200s serfdom

2019-09-19 02:11:36 UTC  

@WP but the dalits had it worst, and china still sucks

2019-09-19 02:11:53 UTC  

hardly anybody could read, nobody needed to read back then

2019-09-19 02:11:59 UTC  

there wasn't anything TO read

2019-09-19 02:12:10 UTC  

hello

2019-09-19 02:12:12 UTC  

@Pelth you're discussing the worst existences humans have suffered in all of human history. a nightmarish world of eternal starvation and oppression

2019-09-19 02:12:22 UTC  

@WP different time period, thats like sayint the cavemen had a higher deathrate so they are dumber

2019-09-19 02:12:33 UTC  

@CallMeTruckson same time period

2019-09-19 02:12:58 UTC  

the serfs only worked as much as they needed to survive pretty much

2019-09-19 02:13:14 UTC  

there were some exceptions here and there of tyranny but that was short lived at best

2019-09-19 02:13:34 UTC  

@Pelth they produced everything they could, and just that left them borderline starving, and then ontop of that shitty subsistence farming then the baron would take a tax

2019-09-19 02:13:56 UTC  

the serf was self sustainable and he gave part of surpluses in tax

2019-09-19 02:13:58 UTC  

@Pelth they lived off scraps of nutritionless grain. their lives were hell

2019-09-19 02:14:35 UTC  

@Pelth they weren't sustainable hence the constant famines. inbetween the famines even then most of them died as infants, if you didn't die as an infant then you probably died in childhood, and if you didn't die in childhood you probably died in adolesence

2019-09-19 02:14:49 UTC  

some serfs did trades and they would exchange their services for food and goods they needed

2019-09-19 02:14:50 UTC  

@Pelth they were actually forced to breed by law

2019-09-19 02:14:56 UTC  

it was quite comfy

2019-09-19 02:15:08 UTC  

@Pelth if they weren't married by around 21 they were put in an arrangedm arriage by their baron to produce more workers

2019-09-19 02:15:22 UTC  

@Pelth they were the worst lives in human history

2019-09-19 02:15:23 UTC  

that was not typical

2019-09-19 02:15:31 UTC  

that seems like a city ordinance

2019-09-19 02:15:36 UTC  

@Pelth it was entirely typical. starvation, death in childhood, famines and so on were the norm

2019-09-19 02:15:40 UTC  

they would have no way to enforce those laws

2019-09-19 02:15:54 UTC  

@Pelth the people in the cities lived comparable luxurious lives with fine wares, lots of money to spend, exotic goods

2019-09-19 02:16:11 UTC  

@Pelth you're a fucking idiot who knows nothing about history and everything you say is wrong

2019-09-19 02:16:18 UTC  

you're just endlessly making up dumb shit that you for some reason wish was true

2019-09-19 02:16:21 UTC  

there usually weren't many laws

2019-09-19 02:16:22 UTC  

you're ignorant as fuck on this subject

2019-09-19 02:16:25 UTC  

you need to stop

2019-09-19 02:16:31 UTC  

justice was enforced by the serfs themselves in many cases

2019-09-19 02:16:33 UTC  

you're a clueless fucking mongoloid who knwos nothing about medieval economy

2019-09-19 02:16:40 UTC  

or by appeal to their lord

2019-09-19 02:16:48 UTC  

you dont' understand anything about serfdom, how it ended, the transition from open field system to agricultural enclosure

2019-09-19 02:17:05 UTC  

you're just some weirdo who got some weird romantic idea of serfdom and wants to make up dumb shit about it

2019-09-19 02:17:24 UTC  

a typical lord would have a handful of permanent soldiers at best

2019-09-19 02:17:31 UTC  

the reality is that in serfdom these people lived in rags, they were so malnutritioned that they usually only grew to about 5 foot to 5 and a half foot tall

2019-09-19 02:17:36 UTC  

literally that was their height

2019-09-19 02:17:52 UTC  

imagine eating so little nutrition that you grew to only 5 and a half foot tall

2019-09-19 02:17:58 UTC  

well, then again, maybe i'm talking to a manlet

2019-09-19 02:18:14 UTC  

the population of medieval europe was actually quite low