Message from @JBlackjackP

Discord ID: 679505294245756928


2020-02-18 23:09:44 UTC  

Didn’t Heidegger hate aesthetics or aestheticism?

2020-02-18 23:09:48 UTC  

Something like that

2020-02-18 23:10:15 UTC  

I barely understand Heidegger most of the time

2020-02-18 23:11:01 UTC  

he hated modern aesthetics

2020-02-18 23:11:33 UTC  

thought they were just a follow on from subjectivism established by the subject/object spilt

2020-02-18 23:11:54 UTC  

Fair enough

2020-02-18 23:13:02 UTC  

you have to understand that Heidegger is trying to bring back a pre-Socratic understanding of truth

2020-02-18 23:13:40 UTC  

Descartes is a disliked figure to say the least

2020-02-18 23:15:36 UTC  

There’s something about uprooting 2200 years of philosophy and reconstructing a new one from the ground up that’s a little pretentious, especially if you have to create a thousand new words to go along with it and Heidegger is a difficult writer

2020-02-18 23:21:36 UTC  

ree
he didn't create a thousand new words he just correctly translated them

2020-02-18 23:21:47 UTC  

but yes he did understand the gravity of his position

2020-02-18 23:22:27 UTC  

he was never overly disrespectful to the thinkers that came before him

2020-02-18 23:23:19 UTC  

Heidegger is a very difficult writer to understand, but it isn't for his word usage but the subjects he is trying to speak on

2020-02-18 23:55:59 UTC  

It would have helped if he used the correct terms for things

2020-02-19 00:12:24 UTC  

?

2020-02-19 00:12:33 UTC  

what things and what terms

2020-02-19 01:04:39 UTC  

also
@clossington in Heidegger's own view his project was not to establish a "new" philosophy from the ground up, he saw it more in line with reviving the pre-socratic traditional, trying to understand it and get back to it thus escaping the pitfalls he saw in the western tradition since Plato

2020-02-19 01:07:03 UTC  

Help me understand the pre-Socratic tradition

2020-02-19 01:08:06 UTC  

He rejected idealism and forms in favor of something like thrown-ness and essentialism

2020-02-19 01:08:30 UTC  

I really don’t know or understand Heidegger

2020-02-19 01:51:26 UTC  

That was just a joke riffing on your reeee I know very little about Heidegger but saying he is trying to revive a pre Socratic tradition makes him seem like the kind of guy who would build a trireme to fight an aircraft carrier

2020-02-19 02:01:31 UTC  

Pull a Civ 4 spearman vs tank

2020-02-19 02:43:30 UTC  

@clossington Thrownness really belongs to being-there as a state-of-being-in-the-world, it is a phenomenological description of a state of being, so it doesn't really directly relate to idealism as a polar opposite. Safe to say Heidegger's relationship with idealism wouldn't be as simple as saying that he outright rejects it.

2020-02-19 02:43:52 UTC  

As to giving you a rundown on Heidegger's view of the pre-socratic tradition, or lack thereof since it was a very loose unity of thinkers, that would take more time and space then I should probably put in this channel.

2020-02-19 02:44:10 UTC  

I could DM you a mini essay I guess

2020-02-19 02:53:51 UTC  

Sure

2020-02-19 02:53:57 UTC  

Links would be nice

2020-02-19 04:59:12 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/668911631937437727/679552545424932887/image0.jpg

2020-02-19 05:05:57 UTC  

>internally screaming

2020-02-19 05:10:20 UTC  

heyo

2020-02-19 05:10:37 UTC  

not quite

2020-02-19 05:10:44 UTC  

Christians only

2020-02-19 05:11:03 UTC  

Intelligence isn't the issue

2020-02-19 05:11:09 UTC  

God is

2020-02-19 05:11:17 UTC  

Or God can tell you

2020-02-19 05:11:44 UTC  

I mean, I wouldn't expect Wakanda

2020-02-19 05:12:00 UTC  

More like our nice bros

2020-02-19 05:13:52 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/668911631937437727/679556235548295178/image0.jpg

2020-02-19 05:14:43 UTC  

Different groups are attracted to different sins, in my view (on average). Some groups might be more attracted to violent sins, while others are more subtle

2020-02-19 05:15:32 UTC  

Homogeny does help societal integrity, don't get me wrong

2020-02-19 05:16:07 UTC  

But I'd rather live with black christians than white pagans