Message from @Grenade123

Discord ID: 463478542995554304


2018-07-02 22:52:49 UTC  

Labor theory of value is Marxist in origin.

2018-07-02 22:53:09 UTC  

yes, but the problem is, that makes everyone equally poor

2018-07-02 22:53:12 UTC  

Perhaps in words, but it exists innately within capitalism

2018-07-02 22:53:20 UTC  

unspoken.

2018-07-02 22:53:31 UTC  

It exists within supply and demand.

2018-07-02 22:53:54 UTC  

because if you follow Marxist theory, we all basically end up farming for ourselves, getting water for ourselves, and building our own house

2018-07-02 22:54:05 UTC  

The point of automation is to decouple human labor from production. But the means of production is still owned by someone.

2018-07-02 22:54:24 UTC  

what happens when you automate the entire process of making and maintaining a machine?

2018-07-02 22:54:29 UTC  

Which explains why countries that adhere to marxist doctrine appear to move backwards in time...

2018-07-02 22:55:06 UTC  

As was said, the entire point of automation is to make widgets cheaper.

2018-07-02 22:55:14 UTC  

which would ultimately the goal of automation

2018-07-02 22:55:15 UTC  

And just because the product of a machine is cheap doesn't mean you give it away. You still expect profit.

2018-07-02 22:55:35 UTC  

Otherwise why build or purchase the machine?

2018-07-02 22:55:43 UTC  

But on the axis of supply and demand

2018-07-02 22:56:08 UTC  

If you've created a huge supply, but you've impoverished the people in the process by cutting out labor

2018-07-02 22:56:09 UTC  

labor is also a shiny object. and it puts some ppl to dissadvantage... children, elderly, disabled

2018-07-02 22:57:10 UTC  

lets say we have 4 machine systems. 1 to make houses, 1 to create food, 1 to distribute water, 1 to maintain, replace, or increase the output of the other 2 systems. All these systems are fully autonomous, meaning its sub components work to get the materials it needs to operate.

2018-07-02 22:57:13 UTC  

If you create huge economic surplus due to automation, you just find different ways of utilizing that surplus. You're going to allocate productivity in different sectors. The ownership class will enjoy more spoils.

2018-07-02 22:57:15 UTC  

You wind up with a massive supply, with little demand due to lack of funds

2018-07-02 22:57:24 UTC  

you now have all your basic human needs met without any human labor

2018-07-02 22:58:15 UTC  

who owns these machines? and how much do they cost? I mean, you don't need to make more machines, the 4th one does it for you. So how much does the bread cost? the water? the house?

2018-07-02 22:58:35 UTC  

no humans are needed to keep this system going or maintain it

2018-07-02 22:58:45 UTC  

the only need for a human is to say when more of something is needed

2018-07-02 22:58:46 UTC  

Grenade, nobody is making those machines for free.

2018-07-02 22:58:59 UTC  

Nobody is investing the time and money to build them expecting no return.

2018-07-02 22:59:21 UTC  

it doesn't matter why they made it, once it is made how much does it cost to maintain?

2018-07-02 22:59:36 UTC  

Yes it matters why they made it because they control them.

2018-07-02 22:59:43 UTC  

machines do... if you go from that point of automotive evolution

2018-07-02 22:59:48 UTC  

ai controls them

2018-07-02 22:59:50 UTC  

1 person verse....literally the world?

2018-07-02 23:00:01 UTC  

They can say if you don't pay me for the use of my machine you don't get the products they make.

2018-07-02 23:00:12 UTC  

and the world revolts

2018-07-02 23:00:19 UTC  

This conversation has become a hypothetical atop a hypothetical.

2018-07-02 23:00:29 UTC  

or they keep using those machines until they die

2018-07-02 23:00:35 UTC  

and someone else makes one

2018-07-02 23:00:42 UTC  

or someone steals the 4th machine

2018-07-02 23:00:47 UTC  

or the tech for it

2018-07-02 23:01:04 UTC  

This discussion is starting to smell like commies.

2018-07-02 23:01:04 UTC  

Or until war breaks down and breaks anywhere between one to four machines

2018-07-02 23:01:20 UTC  

or hacks it to make new copy of everything for them

2018-07-02 23:01:28 UTC  

machines revolt and we extinct... that usualy happen