Message from @MaxKolbe

Discord ID: 488806023293960192


2018-09-10 20:16:55 UTC  

So here's the thing with religion arguments:

What's the endgame? Suppose you convince someone to go to church. This changes what exactly? What goals have you achieved. Suppose you get some people to quit going to church? Does it matter outside religious holidays?

Meanwhile, no one actually is being convinced because it's all stuff that you really can't quantify or reason about anyways. And you alienate everyone.

Stuff like voting and political systems have far more potential impact.

Personally, I would rather discuss tactics for political mobilization

2018-09-10 20:17:02 UTC  

"I can't be bothered to read books or examine studies. I need you to spoonfeed it to me in ways that I personally will arbitrarily decide whether to accept or reject." No thank you. If you aren't willing to engage serious ideas seriously I have no time for you.

2018-09-10 20:17:09 UTC  

But we seem really big on this religion topic.

2018-09-10 20:17:16 UTC  

Asshole, if you can't explain your own faith you're contradicting the bible

2018-09-10 20:17:22 UTC  

And now everyone's just trading insults.

2018-09-10 20:17:56 UTC  

@Vigil You live in an amoral, repercussionless society because it abandoned God, straight up. The lies you tell yourself about religion and those of us who reject your shalow contempt and willful ignorance give those of us who don't share your worldview no reason to give you m uch respect back.

2018-09-10 20:18:03 UTC  

"Read a whole book because I can't sum up a single point of evidence"

2018-09-10 20:18:15 UTC  

I get along with atheists who aren't hateful jackholes making ludicrous generalizations. I dont' get along with Angry Atheist Identitarians with daddy issues.

2018-09-10 20:18:20 UTC  

or who act like they have daddy issues.

2018-09-10 20:18:25 UTC  

which god has been abandoned to make it amoral? we got plenty to pick from, all claiming to be moral

2018-09-10 20:18:37 UTC  

I was being sarcastic. I am still a moral person without God. In fact I became more moral when I abandoned religion since I stopped being as judgemental

2018-09-10 20:18:40 UTC  

@Grenade123 On the science showing most atheists are fatherless, here:

2018-09-10 20:19:16 UTC  

Atheists are over 90% male, and over 90% of them have father issues. That's what the science shows. It also shows autistics more likely to be atheist, though that's still a minority of autistics. It also sh ows most grow out of it.

2018-09-10 20:19:28 UTC  

Is that some actual adhom I see?

2018-09-10 20:19:34 UTC  

always nice to be in the 10% of something good i guess

2018-09-10 20:19:45 UTC  

@Vigil If you became "less judgemental" you're not sshowing it much, with all your hateful shallow easily debunked assertions about those of us who reject your worldview.

2018-09-10 20:19:49 UTC  

out of curiosity, does this hold up with your experience of the atheists you have met?

2018-09-10 20:20:05 UTC  

9/10 atheists you have met have father issues?

2018-09-10 20:20:16 UTC  

Oh, yes, it holds with most atheists I've met. Which is lots and lots. It also holds for me. It also holds for a number of former atheists I've had on my show. 😉

2018-09-10 20:20:37 UTC  

I can't say I've done a formal survey of my contacts, but yes, it's very obvious most of them had no fathers or really crap fathers.

2018-09-10 20:20:44 UTC  

Max, you do realise you haven't provided one case for the existence of God? You've just called me an idiot repeatedly and mocked me for not having a father? It's not very Christian of you to make fun of my bad home situation, is it?

2018-09-10 20:20:45 UTC  

get GC in here and we can make a youtube video

2018-09-10 20:20:51 UTC  

And it's what the science data shows.

2018-09-10 20:21:04 UTC  

I don't remember Commandment 11- Thou Shalt Mock Broken Homes

2018-09-10 20:21:07 UTC  

@Vigil I have provided five right here:

2018-09-10 20:21:16 UTC  

No, Edward Feser provides five there

2018-09-10 20:21:22 UTC  

I have further provided the evidence from Paul VItz's book. I have more if you like.

2018-09-10 20:21:37 UTC  

Do you have any arguments of your own, or are you just a library tannoy system?

2018-09-10 20:22:14 UTC  

@Vigil Yes and they've never been successfully debunked by anyone anywhere, so I suggest you take the time to undertandt hem. What you're showing me now is that you deliberately want to misunderstand, and will simply be abusive and nasty to anyone who disagrees with you. You've been given your evidence, son, now go and look at it and have an adult conversation about it, or, admit this an em otional issue for you not a rational one,.

2018-09-10 20:22:32 UTC  

If he agrees with the argument, even if he's regurgitating it, isn't it still his own since he came to the same conclusion after hearing the evidence?

2018-09-10 20:22:48 UTC  

Don't son me, explain your arguments. I'm not buying a book for an internet debate

2018-09-10 20:23:00 UTC  

Stop hiding behind a book, although I guess you're used to that

2018-09-10 20:23:08 UTC  

LOL I find Digital Physics, Big Bang, NDE data, the moral argument, the historical data, the evolutionary data, and all more than en0ough to satisfy me in my conclusions. What you conclude is up to you, but any claim that I have no evidence, or have given no evidence, or that I am irrational is a false claim.\

2018-09-10 20:23:19 UTC  

We killed god

2018-09-10 20:23:19 UTC  

@cipher\

2018-09-10 20:23:22 UTC  

There is no definitive cause for the Big Bang

2018-09-10 20:23:34 UTC  

@Vigil You are acting like a childish little boy with daddy issues wyho can't be bothered to discuss hard ideas.

2018-09-10 20:23:58 UTC  

Right, I'm kinda about done with you now. I don't think you see the irony, and it's actually sad

2018-09-10 20:24:02 UTC  

Your religious beliefs are being challenged, your worldview being criticized. You can't handle it so you ignore all data and all science that you don't like. Very SJW, very feminist.