unless ur arguments is that the President's life is now public propierty or something like that

not the rest of twitter users

Sure. But would it hold up if not everyone can access it?

the rest of twitter isn't a public forum

Exactly!

so is that about public forums but about the behaviour of the president while he is in office

You see my point!

just his twitter, specifically his tweets

is not*

kk

In order for declaring the public space

that is the official ruling

you would have to declare a public path TO that public space.

well perfect, now twitter can unban conservatives

That's what I've been getting at this whole time.

then the leftists will scream

Yuuuuup

and either the ruling will be reversed, or twitter will die

We're on the same page, now.

still not seeing the downside of this ruling regardless

Does a President have a right to a personal public life while in office?

I'm not saying there IS a downside

I'm saying it's a case of activist leftists being shortsighted as they are want to be.

i mean, it was never in question who wanted this

Oh, right.

So, what I think we've been arguing this whole time

it was only if it was valid

are the two perspectives, both of which would crack this decision open

Because in the example I gave before....

```
1. Any action taken by the president is an action of the government
2. Donald Trump's personal twitter account is to be considered an open public forum
3. Twitter, as a whole, as a privately owned company, may remain a private forum```

2 and 3 can't coexist.

I mean, I guess technically, they can

But unless we get activist decisions up through the supreme court

it's going to give.

ok I get it now

Either Everyone gets Twitter

the life of the President belong to the govt while he is in office, something like that

or Trump gets to block people.

Either way, they've got a bad day ahead of themselves for even trying.

The only way, realistically, for Trump's private account to be upheld as a public forum

is for all of twitter to be opened