chat

Discord ID: 496515828372602890


158,305 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev | Page 401/1584 | Next

2018-10-06 04:51:15 UTC

Daily reminder saunas are good for your heart

2018-10-06 04:51:30 UTC

We will need healthy hearts when the civil war reignites

2018-10-06 04:51:46 UTC

@Cawaii Why are you an atheist.

2018-10-06 04:52:05 UTC

You picked the literal worst option.

2018-10-06 04:52:07 UTC

now it's better

2018-10-06 04:52:26 UTC

can't lie tbh

2018-10-06 04:52:32 UTC

I am not really religious

2018-10-06 04:52:45 UTC

Theism has nothing to do with religion though.

2018-10-06 04:52:53 UTC

perhaps

2018-10-06 04:53:08 UTC

I was brought up in a Muslim conservative country

2018-10-06 04:53:28 UTC

I can label myself as an exmuslim

2018-10-06 04:53:36 UTC

So I assume you've read the Kalam Cosmological Argument

2018-10-06 04:53:51 UTC

I haven't

2018-10-06 04:54:46 UTC

@Cawaii

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore the universe has a cause.
4. There cannot be an infinite regress of causes.
5. There cannot be a circular causation.
6. Therefore the universe was caused (either directly or indirectly) by an uncaused cause (i.e that had no beginning).
7. The uncaused cause must transcend space and time, and be sentient.
8. But to say a sentient being that transcends space and time brought the universe into existence, is to say that God exists.
9. Therefore God exists.

2018-10-06 04:56:36 UTC

One of my main points of Agnostic view is the "I'll believe it when I see it" argument, and I love to factor in the ideas that there could be more Gods than thought and believed on the planet Earth, and a true God could exist as the Universe

2018-10-06 04:56:59 UTC

I'll believe it when I see it is anchoring truth to empiricism

2018-10-06 04:57:03 UTC

Which is subjective/a preference

2018-10-06 04:57:56 UTC

if brett likes bud lite he shouldnt be in the supreme court

2018-10-06 04:58:44 UTC

True, empiricism really does lock out certain theories and arguments necessary for understanding the universe around us, but the basis of being an Agnostic is purely being subjective.

2018-10-06 04:59:05 UTC

Does God exist or not, I'll believe it when I see it.

2018-10-06 04:59:31 UTC

>when I see it

2018-10-06 04:59:40 UTC

how would you be able to "see" omniscience and omnipotence?

2018-10-06 04:59:47 UTC

hint: you can't

2018-10-06 05:00:16 UTC

It all comes back down to being subjective.

2018-10-06 05:00:22 UTC

that's not an argument

2018-10-06 05:00:35 UTC

you're just saying outright "lol I don't care because it's my opinion"

2018-10-06 05:00:44 UTC

Without God you have an infinite regress of subjectivity

2018-10-06 05:01:09 UTC

btw calling something subjective is an objective claim about subjectivity, which imo undermines the ontological potency of subjectivist arguments

2018-10-06 05:01:12 UTC

nothing is subjective

2018-10-06 05:01:14 UTC

that is a meme

2018-10-06 05:01:22 UTC

Empiricism can be embedded within a greater science, which can be embedded in a greater science, within a greater science, etc.

2018-10-06 05:03:12 UTC

So just out of curiosity, is your theist belief the belief that god is the cosmos?

2018-10-06 05:03:23 UTC

No

2018-10-06 05:03:29 UTC

To me, He is the Unmoved Mover

2018-10-06 05:03:35 UTC

Can you elaborate?

2018-10-06 05:03:50 UTC

^ the 9 point argument I posted

2018-10-06 05:04:01 UTC

He is the anchor to the causal chain

2018-10-06 05:04:32 UTC

He exists outside the natural world, He is the unactualized actualizer.

2018-10-06 05:04:43 UTC

He initiated all movement. The Unmoved Mover.

2018-10-06 05:04:45 UTC

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/496515828372602890/497997619923124236/1505096343126.png

2018-10-06 05:04:50 UTC

God bless America

2018-10-06 05:05:01 UTC

๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿผ

2018-10-06 05:08:17 UTC

Well fuck me I guess I just became a Theist

2018-10-06 05:08:21 UTC

That makes too much sense

2018-10-06 05:08:27 UTC

<:RedPill:356316562057068545>

2018-10-06 05:09:06 UTC

lol

2018-10-06 05:09:33 UTC

why is ezra mod not senior mod

2018-10-06 05:09:38 UTC

I thought he was senior mod

2018-10-06 05:09:45 UTC

good

2018-10-06 05:10:16 UTC

Well the more I think about it the more it makes more sense because that this God would exist outside of the space of reality since It created the space, so it doesn't have to follow the standard laws of Physics that we understand or try to understand now.

2018-10-06 05:10:39 UTC

Correct.

2018-10-06 05:10:40 UTC

Since you can't have an infinite explosion and regression of the universe like some would theorize to the beginning of *our* universe now, something had to have started the space

2018-10-06 05:11:02 UTC

yes

2018-10-06 05:11:11 UTC

you're getting there

2018-10-06 05:11:16 UTC

so what god is that

2018-10-06 05:11:18 UTC

This thing could bend its own physics and think itself into existence and we wouldn't be able to explain it with our own physics, because he created the space that those physics exist and he's outside of that space

2018-10-06 05:11:25 UTC

@GrandxSlam *trinity

2018-10-06 05:11:36 UTC

*trinity

2018-10-06 05:11:50 UTC

Correct, you are making the right inferences.

2018-10-06 05:12:02 UTC

who knows

2018-10-06 05:12:18 UTC

@Ben well hang on, God didn't think itself into existence

2018-10-06 05:12:24 UTC

So once that's settled, the question becomes which religion is correct?

2018-10-06 05:12:27 UTC

God is eternal

2018-10-06 05:12:38 UTC

always existent

2018-10-06 05:12:42 UTC

No i think he means God could will himself into the physical realm

2018-10-06 05:12:42 UTC

everything has a begining though

2018-10-06 05:12:58 UTC

not God

2018-10-06 05:13:02 UTC

because God is outside of our universe

2018-10-06 05:13:08 UTC

Exactly, the physics that we try to use to explain the creation of this God are completely irrelevant because he doesn't exist within that sphere, he's outside of those powers.

2018-10-06 05:13:21 UTC

Yes but he could break physics and insert himself in our universe if He pleased

2018-10-06 05:13:22 UTC

how do we know that

2018-10-06 05:13:40 UTC

yeah, that's the problem with the "well who created god" argument @Ben

2018-10-06 05:13:45 UTC

He did

2018-10-06 05:13:50 UTC

He can will that thought of existence

2018-10-06 05:14:14 UTC

He is not confined to space-time. Space-time is a limitation of the physical world.

2018-10-06 05:14:16 UTC

There's no reasonable physical theory we can make up and prove because he isn't under that control

2018-10-06 05:14:22 UTC

God is therefore eternal.

2018-10-06 05:14:41 UTC

Right, the scope of empiricism is the natural world and the natural world only.

2018-10-06 05:15:04 UTC

i don't know, it sounds like a perfect excuse, how can you disprove something thats not even in our uhh, realm of existance or whatnot

2018-10-06 05:15:21 UTC

i just don't understand how we know all this in the first place

2018-10-06 05:15:29 UTC

How do we know anything?

2018-10-06 05:15:33 UTC

That is philosophy

2018-10-06 05:15:36 UTC

The religious server

2018-10-06 05:15:46 UTC

We don't know in the first place, it's a belief

2018-10-06 05:15:48 UTC

It's Theism

2018-10-06 05:16:07 UTC

The same way that you would think of a Christian God

2018-10-06 05:16:22 UTC

man idk, i am just filled with doubt about everything in the cosmos at this point

2018-10-06 05:17:42 UTC

Thomas Aquinas dedicated his life to these questions btw

2018-10-06 05:17:58 UTC

He was looking to prove Christianity as a philosopher first, believer second.

2018-10-06 05:19:12 UTC

Shadow Warrior 2 currently free!

2018-10-06 05:19:49 UTC

@GrandxSlam What do you anchor truth to? Empiricism?

2018-10-06 05:20:03 UTC

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/496515828372602890/498001471858540545/SmartSelect_20181005-231955_Instagram.jpg

2018-10-06 05:22:14 UTC

Can someone explain to me why Centrism is looked down upon?

2018-10-06 05:22:26 UTC

@Ben Centrism is apathy

2018-10-06 05:22:27 UTC

It is pragmatism at its worst

2018-10-06 05:22:28 UTC

Apathy is death

2018-10-06 05:22:58 UTC

Is centrism based on a principle?

2018-10-06 05:23:22 UTC

Yes

158,305 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev | Page 401/1584 | Next