catechumen-question-time

Discord ID: 592839808783745024


568 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Page 1/6 | Next

2019-06-24 22:17:04 UTC

SSPX IS NAZBOL <:nazbol:589142322076319745>

2019-06-24 22:17:29 UTC

Imagine being SSPX when you can be FSSP

2019-06-24 22:20:11 UTC

Imagine being SSPX when you can be in communion

2019-06-24 22:25:53 UTC

Imagine being FSSP when you can be ICKSP

2019-06-24 23:43:01 UTC

Imagine thinking the faithful who attend SSPX Mass aren't in communion, as they confess regularly and receive the Eucharist.

2019-06-24 23:43:27 UTC

It's the Society itself which is canonically irregular, not the faithful

2019-06-24 23:43:51 UTC

It's been made clear that Catholics can fulfill their obligation by attending SSPX masses

2019-06-24 23:45:03 UTC

@Wrath I'm confirmed and am in communion, role please

2019-06-25 00:22:00 UTC

What do all these acronyms mean

2019-06-25 00:24:25 UTC

Theย Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peterย (Latin:ย Fraternitas Sacerdotalis Sancti Petri;ย FSSP)
Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX)

2019-06-25 00:44:23 UTC

And, then, the Institute of Christ the King Sovereign Priest, which I continue to maintain is infinitely better than the Society and the Fraternity.

2019-06-25 00:47:40 UTC

My issue with the Fraternity of St Peter being that they are 1962 to their very core. Which, when indults to celebrate the pre-1955 liturgy are so readily available, appears almost rather uncaring on the part of their priests.

2019-06-25 01:17:26 UTC

@GodFearingEnglishman Do you go to ICKS too?

2019-06-25 01:20:47 UTC

No, their presence in England is few and far in between.

2019-06-25 01:21:05 UTC

I believe they celebrate Mass in a total of two places.

2019-06-25 01:25:27 UTC

No, six.

2019-06-25 01:25:54 UTC

Though, three are in the same city, one is a convent, and another is their school.

2019-06-26 23:19:04 UTC

So whatโ€™s the difference if any between limbo and purgatory

2019-06-26 23:19:29 UTC

I think Purgatory you eventually go to Heaven?

2019-06-26 23:19:52 UTC

and Limbo you're there forever, and Limbo isn't that bad either, it's just that you're separated from God

2019-06-26 23:20:02 UTC

I thought so too but Iโ€™ve heard limbo and purgatory be used interchangeably so Iโ€™m confused

2019-06-26 23:22:26 UTC

Doesn't seem like it, Purgatory eventually leads you to Heaven after being cleansed

2019-06-26 23:24:18 UTC

Oh ok

2019-06-26 23:24:56 UTC

You eventually go to Heaven in purgatory. Many faithful in mexico before secularism used the Day of the dead to pray for those still in purgatory. However with secularism theyve made the holiday paganistic.

2019-06-26 23:25:25 UTC

fucking modernist

2019-06-26 23:25:32 UTC

My great aunts still use Day of the dead to go and visit the tombs of their relatives to pray

2019-06-26 23:25:52 UTC

I believe they pray a Rosary

2019-06-26 23:26:16 UTC

@MawLr based faithful

2019-06-26 23:26:18 UTC

So I suppose you could say they kept the tradition in the Catholic way

2019-06-26 23:27:05 UTC

@MawLr i mean thats how it is traditionally celebrated. Instead we got stuck with confused faithful giving offering to phantasmal beast

2019-06-26 23:27:25 UTC

Never liked those pagan things

2019-06-26 23:28:01 UTC

i used to like aesthethically along time ago. but then I realized wait it dont make sense

2019-06-26 23:28:15 UTC

Same with how they desecrated the All Hallows eve

2019-06-26 23:28:42 UTC

nigga, I have to deal with such a dark day praying and I get these children asking for things

2019-06-26 23:29:04 UTC

oh yeah almost forgot about that

2019-06-27 00:09:00 UTC

@Mac tรญre iarain Limbo was the place all of the Godly people went until Jesus descended into Limbo and opened the gates of Heaven to them. In essence, it doesn't really exist anymore because the gates of Heaven are open to all, since Jesus' proclamation. Purgatory is where souls go to be purified before they are ascended to Heaven. Difference is; Limbo was where purified souls couldn't go into Heaven, Purgatory is where unpurified souls are cleansed before they go to Heaven

2019-06-27 00:13:08 UTC

^

2019-06-27 00:13:24 UTC

Which means the souls in Limbo made it to Heaven

2019-06-27 00:15:01 UTC

Ah nice

2019-06-27 00:15:39 UTC

@Deleted User so do we all go through purgatory or how do we cleanse our souls?

2019-06-27 00:15:52 UTC

I believe so, yes, unless you die in Grace

2019-06-27 00:16:10 UTC

The promise of the Scapular is that if you die with it and in a state of Grace, you go directly to Heaven

2019-06-27 00:16:35 UTC

_it's free real state_

2019-06-27 00:16:54 UTC

I couldn't tell you @Mac tรญre iarain

2019-06-27 01:00:58 UTC

@Mac tรญre iarain purgatory isnt necesarily a bad thing but its like a court hearing that is usually in your favor. Unless youve been bad all your life.

2019-06-27 01:01:11 UTC

like lukewarm and all that.

2019-06-27 01:01:42 UTC

Purgatory ain't gonna tickle

2019-06-27 01:02:40 UTC

I highly recommend hearing what Catholic Answer has to say on purgatory. Im horrible at explaining things.

2019-06-27 01:04:25 UTC

Purgatory isn't a "court hearing", as it were.

2019-06-27 01:04:51 UTC

It's not a bad thing though

2019-06-27 01:04:58 UTC

When you die, you are judged. It is then that you will either go to Heaven, Hell, or Purgatory.

2019-06-27 01:05:34 UTC

If you have showed heroic virtue in your life, you will probably go straight to Heaven.

2019-06-27 01:05:55 UTC

And we all know why folks go to Hell.

2019-06-27 01:06:38 UTC

As for purgatory, if we still have the stain of venial sins, we will be cleansed of them in Purgatory before going to Heaven.

2019-06-27 01:06:45 UTC

Purged of your sins.

2019-06-27 01:06:59 UTC

Not mortal sins though

2019-06-27 01:07:05 UTC

Those send your ass to hell

2019-06-27 01:07:10 UTC

Likely so.

2019-06-27 01:07:23 UTC

But, there are occasions where our Lord brings forth his infinite mercy.

2019-06-27 01:07:40 UTC

Those occasions are few and far in between, though.

2019-06-27 01:08:30 UTC

So if I confess my mortal sins before I die am I good?

2019-06-27 01:08:35 UTC

Yes

2019-06-27 01:08:38 UTC

yup

2019-06-27 01:08:48 UTC

those after your baptism

2019-06-27 01:08:58 UTC

But.

2019-06-27 01:09:24 UTC

If you would repeat those same sins consciously after you confessed them the first time... are you truly contrite?

2019-06-27 01:11:06 UTC

We are fallen beings, and God is well aware of this. When you confess, I am quite sure you have absolutely no intention of sinning again, and, in spite of that, you obviously do.

2019-06-27 01:11:29 UTC

7 times 70 times more

2019-06-27 01:12:00 UTC

if youre doing it to spite God, you got another thing coming.

2019-06-27 01:12:10 UTC

Your confession is centred mainly around your intention. Might you commit a certain sin in future? There is no way of telling. Do you, however, have any intention of committing that sin again? Likely not.

2019-06-27 01:12:49 UTC

The priest giving the sermon at my parish for All Souls Day last year said, rather accurately, that Purgatory is the most joyous place in the entire universe outside of Heaven. His reason for saying so was that everybody in Purgatory has been guaranteed their place in Heaven once they have eventually been purged of their sins.

2019-06-27 06:23:41 UTC

@Mozalbete โณฉ thoughts? Or has it been explained pretty well?

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/592839808783745024/593687884012453890/unknown.png

2019-06-27 06:26:28 UTC

If you repented and had no plans to repeat the sin, of course you are contrite

2019-06-27 06:27:04 UTC

I don't get where people get this idea that if you repeat a sin you never repented in the first time, which contradicts scripture, the Fathers, the saints, and pretty much all of Christianity

2019-06-27 06:27:16 UTC

It's more just doubting myself is all

2019-06-27 06:28:04 UTC

Don't get obsessed with it. Matthew 18:21-22

2019-06-27 06:28:05 UTC

**Matthew 18:21-22 - Douay-Rheims 1899 American Edition (DRA)**

```Dust


<21> Then came Peter unto him and said: Lord, how often shall my brother offend against me, and I forgive him? till seven times? <22> Jesus saith to him: I say not to thee, till seven times; but till seventy times seven times. ```

2019-06-27 08:10:01 UTC

@Mozalbete โณฉ Do you have any documents on demonic oppression?

2019-06-27 08:10:13 UTC

And or possession or demons in general

2019-06-27 08:10:17 UTC

Nope

2019-06-27 08:10:23 UTC

I know, not a subject we are supposed to talk about

2019-06-27 08:10:33 UTC

But I would maybe read from good exorcists

2019-06-27 08:10:43 UTC

Like St. Benedict?

2019-06-27 08:10:53 UTC

Idk if he wrote anything

2019-06-27 08:10:55 UTC

Thing is, I don't really know who are good exorcists

2019-06-27 08:11:08 UTC

hmm

2019-06-27 08:11:20 UTC

But it may be a good idea to look at modern ones (that are good)

2019-06-27 08:11:49 UTC

here in italy we have father Amorth which has published many books about his experiences with demons and exorcisms

2019-06-27 08:11:58 UTC

i dont know if you can find them translated

2019-06-27 08:12:04 UTC

Damn

2019-06-27 08:12:21 UTC

It's a question I often get asked to explain is all and I feel ill prepared for it

2019-06-27 08:12:58 UTC

oh yes

2019-06-27 08:13:03 UTC

actually there are some translated

2019-06-27 08:13:07 UTC

i just saw them

2019-06-27 08:39:16 UTC

Can you send some links? <:shockedcat:591726182010191872>

2019-06-27 08:39:18 UTC
2019-06-27 08:52:00 UTC

Damn, just after I found a copy on my own too

2019-06-27 08:52:02 UTC

:p

568 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Page 1/6 | Next