Message from @Pyro

Discord ID: 514316349112320000


2018-11-20 05:47:08 UTC  

its better than nothing

2018-11-20 05:47:16 UTC  

and the legislative branch can always supersede those decisions

2018-11-20 05:47:21 UTC  

it's not crazy

2018-11-20 05:47:23 UTC  

and remove any judges they want

2018-11-20 05:47:25 UTC  

It cant

2018-11-20 05:47:36 UTC  

go to civics class

2018-11-20 05:47:51 UTC  

The Consititution can just be ammended.

2018-11-20 05:48:03 UTC  

Judicial review and judicial precedent makes it essential illegal to make a law prohibiting abortion

2018-11-20 05:48:04 UTC  

which is probably impossible now

2018-11-20 05:48:06 UTC  

in particular, the senate can basically tell the supreme court to fuck off

2018-11-20 05:48:24 UTC  

or more often, when the supreme court is not deciding the raw constitutionality of something, the constitution need not be amended.

2018-11-20 05:48:25 UTC  

not the house, but at least the senate can

2018-11-20 05:48:25 UTC  

Not written down as law, but has the same power as law

2018-11-20 05:48:52 UTC  

it is illegal to prohibit abortion in the first trimester

2018-11-20 05:48:52 UTC  

yes

2018-11-20 05:48:59 UTC  

Its basically 9 people deciding on new constitutional amendments

2018-11-20 05:48:59 UTC  

the argument was stupid

2018-11-20 05:49:17 UTC  

the constitution needs an amendment to prohibit first-trimester abortion

2018-11-20 05:49:28 UTC  

because of search and seizure or some shit

2018-11-20 05:49:31 UTC  

that fell on everyone then. The judges, the elected officials who were afraid of dissenting with popular opinion...

2018-11-20 05:49:33 UTC  

u do know that it takes a large majority of congress just to add an ammendment right?

2018-11-20 05:49:37 UTC  

yeah, five people had a shitty argument once

2018-11-20 05:49:59 UTC  

republicans, had they spines, could have reversed it

2018-11-20 05:50:07 UTC  

Your point @Pyro ?

2018-11-20 05:50:22 UTC  

Cause ofc I'm aware

2018-11-20 05:50:26 UTC  

that with divided politics, it's impossible

2018-11-20 05:50:33 UTC  

Unless your the scotus

2018-11-20 05:50:38 UTC  

there are ample opportunities to override the supreme court's opinions from the legislature

2018-11-20 05:50:40 UTC  

they choose not to

2018-11-20 05:50:45 UTC  

and that is the main reason it doesn't happen

2018-11-20 05:50:47 UTC  

Then you can just say something is unconstitutional and its illegal

2018-11-20 05:51:01 UTC  

Cause of Judicial review

2018-11-20 05:51:01 UTC  

now republicans being cowards, and democrats being batshit crazy cultists is another matter

2018-11-20 05:51:14 UTC  

generally speaking, laws prohibiting first-trimester abortion are not constitutional

2018-11-20 05:51:15 UTC  

yes

2018-11-20 05:51:27 UTC  

unfortunately thats true

2018-11-20 05:51:43 UTC  

the constitution must be amended, in order for the answer to change

2018-11-20 05:51:50 UTC  

they did that by changing the definition of life...

2018-11-20 05:51:51 UTC  

this prevents double jeopardy, which is great

2018-11-20 05:51:55 UTC  

and prevents waste

2018-11-20 05:52:11 UTC  

however, the downside is that you get stuck with things