Message from @Fran

Discord ID: 666088753990991872


2020-01-13 01:13:24 UTC  

yeeeeeey

2020-01-13 01:13:24 UTC  

Interesting

2020-01-13 01:13:28 UTC  

But there are

2020-01-13 01:13:56 UTC  

yeah well, who cares, right? if i cant understand something, means it aint real

2020-01-13 01:14:01 UTC  

Isn't charge indicated with negative numbers or positive numbers?

2020-01-13 01:14:07 UTC  

thats the way to go

2020-01-13 01:14:41 UTC  

Mhm

2020-01-13 01:14:59 UTC  

> If the rest mass of the photon were non-zero, the theory of quantum electrodynamics would be "in trouble" primarily through loss of gauge invariance, which would make it non-renormalisable; also, charge conservation would no longer be absolutely guaranteed, as it is if photons have zero rest mass.

2020-01-13 01:16:22 UTC  

if the rest mass were non zero

2020-01-13 01:16:57 UTC  

I've been saying it's massless

2020-01-13 01:16:58 UTC  

its a way of looking at it theoretically

2020-01-13 01:17:28 UTC  

rest mass being non zero means not massless

2020-01-13 01:17:37 UTC  

But regardless of what any theory might predict, it is still necessary to check this prediction by doing an experiment.

It is almost certainly impossible to do any experiment that would establish the photon rest mass to be exactly zero

2020-01-13 01:17:44 UTC  

and yea its mostly theoretics

2020-01-13 01:17:46 UTC  

^^^ meaning they cant test for it

2020-01-13 01:17:51 UTC  

If the rest mass were nonzero it's saying we'd run into issues with qed

2020-01-13 01:18:33 UTC  

you cant test most of the stuff with protons

2020-01-13 01:18:37 UTC  

photons

2020-01-13 01:18:39 UTC  

*

2020-01-13 01:18:54 UTC  

You can't test most of the stuff with cosmology

2020-01-13 01:18:56 UTC  

Or geology

2020-01-13 01:19:05 UTC  

so the idea is, as far as my non physics trained brain gets it, that it is zero all the time, but they need it to be nonzero at rest

2020-01-13 01:20:00 UTC  

yes you can?? @Fran especially geology

2020-01-13 01:20:25 UTC  

well thats a long story

2020-01-13 01:20:27 UTC  

cosmology not as much

2020-01-13 01:20:29 UTC  

Can you test the formation of million year old rock formations?

2020-01-13 01:20:33 UTC  

(get it? geology, long story?)

2020-01-13 01:20:42 UTC  

yes

2020-01-13 01:20:46 UTC  

how lol

2020-01-13 01:20:48 UTC  

carbon dating

2020-01-13 01:21:05 UTC  

what he meant is that u cant replicate it in the lab

2020-01-13 01:21:15 UTC  

you dont have to

2020-01-13 01:21:22 UTC  

Yeah I don't mean test to just observe some properties

2020-01-13 01:21:32 UTC  

can you recreate the formation of a grand canyon in a lab

2020-01-13 01:21:35 UTC  

well ure both right and wrong at the same time

2020-01-13 01:21:39 UTC  

with time yes

2020-01-13 01:21:40 UTC  

can you test the theory for it's formation

2020-01-13 01:21:52 UTC  

yes just not in one life time

2020-01-13 01:21:55 UTC  

lol if you think that is at all feesible

2020-01-13 01:22:05 UTC  

you can also 'test' supernovas then