Message from @hgb

Discord ID: 675491888358228028


2020-02-07 23:59:29 UTC  

larger

2020-02-07 23:59:51 UTC  

following inverse gravitational square law

2020-02-07 23:59:52 UTC  

That's what the centre of mass method predicts, right?

2020-02-07 23:59:56 UTC  

no?

2020-02-08 00:00:00 UTC  

i just told you

2020-02-08 00:00:06 UTC  

But in reality, if you're there, obviously, your gravity would be less than g

2020-02-08 00:00:09 UTC  

the inverse gravitational law

2020-02-08 00:00:15 UTC  

thats not true

2020-02-08 00:00:21 UTC  

Okay.

2020-02-08 00:00:25 UTC  

Think about it.

2020-02-08 00:00:53 UTC  

You're at the centre of the earth. Inverse square law predicts near infinite force there, correct?

2020-02-08 00:01:01 UTC  

no

2020-02-08 00:01:12 UTC  

Well say 0.0000001 m away from centre of earth

2020-02-08 00:01:15 UTC  

ok

2020-02-08 00:01:22 UTC  

You would have a humongously large force

2020-02-08 00:01:24 UTC  

But

2020-02-08 00:01:35 UTC  

You have equal mass in any direction from you.

2020-02-08 00:01:54 UTC  

See what I mean?

2020-02-08 00:03:03 UTC  

The centre of mass model is good if, well, we consider masses to be point masses.

2020-02-08 00:03:08 UTC  

But not so otherwise.

2020-02-08 00:03:36 UTC  

Because if I cut the earth into two, and stand in the middle, then they would exert equal and opposite force on me

2020-02-08 00:03:55 UTC  

Because they have centres of masses in at different locations

2020-02-08 00:04:12 UTC  

Which contradicts the prediction made by considering solely the centre of the earth

2020-02-08 00:04:32 UTC  

They would now be two different objects. their gravity would be reliant on the mass of each half. It would not be equal as each half of the earth is not equal

2020-02-08 00:04:39 UTC  

Which is I would have a massive force on me, and the immediate moment I cross the centre, that massive force inverts in direction.

2020-02-08 00:04:49 UTC  

Yea

2020-02-08 00:05:01 UTC  

Do you genuinely believe this

2020-02-08 00:05:15 UTC  

That in the dead centre of the earth, I have infinite force

2020-02-08 00:05:28 UTC  

so for a split second you would feel the force decrease to 0 as you have an opposite and equal force applying pushing you into an equilibrium

2020-02-08 00:05:28 UTC  

no

2020-02-08 00:05:32 UTC  

because

2020-02-08 00:05:40 UTC  

Yes,

2020-02-08 00:05:42 UTC  

But

2020-02-08 00:05:43 UTC  

that implies an infinite mass

2020-02-08 00:05:46 UTC  

On the two sides

2020-02-08 00:05:47 UTC  

which is doesnt have

2020-02-08 00:05:54 UTC  

You have a duck load of force

2020-02-08 00:05:59 UTC  

Yea

2020-02-08 00:06:02 UTC  

not infinte

2020-02-08 00:06:03 UTC  

or close

2020-02-08 00:06:09 UTC  

Why is the centre of the earth not a singularity then xD