Message from @Inazuma

Discord ID: 505489968546971680


2018-10-26 15:42:16 UTC  

not really

2018-10-26 17:10:14 UTC  

Cannons are supposed to rip bombers to shreds tho

2018-10-26 17:10:43 UTC  

MEANWHILE

2018-10-26 17:11:11 UTC  

FUCKING FIDDY CALS RIP YOU APART AND SET YOU ON FIRE FROM OVER 1.5 KMS

2018-10-26 17:14:07 UTC  

🤔

2018-10-26 17:47:05 UTC  

Aight, chill.

2018-10-26 21:00:39 UTC  

@Inazuma
I mean in war thunder they are super fragile.
Historically, unless the lone fighter destroyed the tail control or killed the pilot and co pilot, he stood no real chance in taking down an Fortress, Liberator, or Super Fortress.
You can't just shear through the entirety of the bomber's wing with a few 20mm cannon rounds, let alone a handful of .50cals like Gaijin has gone and displayed.

2018-10-26 21:01:12 UTC  

[*Laughs in German cannons*]

2018-10-26 21:01:44 UTC  

I'm aware how good German cannons are my guy

2018-10-26 21:01:51 UTC  

Post war testing showed even a couple 30mm shots shattered a B17 clean

2018-10-26 21:01:59 UTC  

20mm was the same

2018-10-26 21:02:19 UTC  

Yes, a burst from 4 MG 108 30mm cannons will surely do the job

2018-10-26 21:03:05 UTC  

But in the air from actual combat reports, a lone fighter with 1 or 2 20mm cannons isn't just gonna tap the trigger, take off your entire steel constructed wing, and then fly off like Gaijin thinks

2018-10-26 21:04:49 UTC  

The introduction of the MG 108 and MG 103 was a whole new phase in bomber hunting that took a new turn with new developments

2018-10-26 21:06:24 UTC  

I'm talking about your wise guy 109 or spaceship Spitnig that has no more than 1 second of ToT (Time on target) and your bomber just falls apart like Papier-mâché

2018-10-26 21:14:47 UTC  

Yeah no

2018-10-26 21:15:08 UTC  

A lone bomber vs a german fighter has no chance

2018-10-26 21:15:23 UTC  

or any fighter tbh

2018-10-26 21:15:24 UTC  

Extremely situational

2018-10-26 21:15:42 UTC  

From all reports on the Axis and Allies side it is extremely situational my guy

2018-10-26 21:16:40 UTC  

Those bombers are only tough against flak, fighter fire will easily rip apart an aircraft. The problem is actually aiming and scoring a hit

2018-10-26 21:16:54 UTC  

That's just not true though

2018-10-26 21:16:57 UTC  

A big target with no cover by itself is an easy kill for any fighter

2018-10-26 21:17:38 UTC  

Some of the largest batches of info of German Fighters vs B-17s is from Operation Husky

2018-10-26 21:17:46 UTC  

The allied invasion of Sicily

2018-10-26 21:18:32 UTC  

In that theatre, Mid -1943 That was really the peak of both the Allies and Axis side with overall performance

2018-10-26 21:18:34 UTC  

@RoflTank You know more about this

2018-10-26 21:19:49 UTC  

Time and time again you saw where yeah, in some situations there would be a German fighter that gets the hits it needs to kill the B-17, in other situations the B-17 would take what it had to give and more, while still making it home. The majority of B-17s lost in Husky was due to the overwhelming amount of Flak placed in key areas of the Island

2018-10-26 21:19:53 UTC  

It depends if the gunners get a licks shot

2018-10-26 21:20:08 UTC  

And that's the fucking B-17

2018-10-26 21:20:34 UTC  

A good hit by a .50 to the pilot or engine could force the attacking fighter to break off or kill it outright

2018-10-26 21:21:20 UTC  

The B-17 was an outdated heavy bomber (designed in 1936), going slow enough for a fucking Bi-plane to catch it

2018-10-26 21:21:38 UTC  

By the time of 1943 that is

2018-10-26 21:21:47 UTC  

Up until 43 it was fine

2018-10-26 21:21:54 UTC  

but it was pushing it's luck that far

2018-10-26 21:23:30 UTC  

@Magos Squid "The Life Raft" During and post-war, testing showed that a single Mk108 30mm firing HEM needed only 5 rounds to cause catastrophic airframe failure on your average bomber.

2018-10-26 21:23:52 UTC  

Well yeah, that's the best thing they had

2018-10-26 21:23:59 UTC  

I'm talking about the average 20mm cannon

2018-10-26 21:24:15 UTC  

20mm HEM needed significantly more shells, something like 40-60, mainly because while it had a fuckload of HE per shell, it was still a tiny 20mm shell.

2018-10-26 21:24:33 UTC  

MG 151/20 and in comparison Hispano Mk.Vs, AN/M2s, and then whatever the fuck the Nips used

2018-10-26 21:24:54 UTC  

Meanwhile 30mm HEM model A had like... 85g of HE, more than most bomber-hunter 37mm guns had in their HE shells