Message from @Thomas the Sowell Train [USA]

Discord ID: 380769584870981642


2017-11-16 17:15:01 UTC  

it can be used interchangibly with "freedom fighter" from the other side

2017-11-16 17:15:17 UTC  

But for the sake of argument, can we not assume that a particular individual is very much a terrorist?

2017-11-16 17:15:36 UTC  

i think its better to actually examine suspented 'terrorists' on the merits of their methods and goals

2017-11-16 17:16:39 UTC  

This is really skirting around the point of my older question, so I'll ask a different one. Should someone with a warrant for murder be able to vote?

2017-11-16 17:16:52 UTC  

to answer your question, no , i dont think we can justify denying voting rights to 'terrorists' because the word terrorist has no clear definition beyond "enemies of the state"

2017-11-16 17:17:12 UTC  

ah ok

2017-11-16 17:17:18 UTC  

with a warrant? them trying to vote would naturally set off a few bells

2017-11-16 17:17:29 UTC  

Not if we don't require IDs.

2017-11-16 17:17:39 UTC  

i would definitely require an ID

2017-11-16 17:17:45 UTC  

and make IDs totally free

2017-11-16 17:18:03 UTC  

Paid for by tax dollars?

2017-11-16 17:18:32 UTC  

well yea i can easily justify taxation if its a benefit given to literally everybody

2017-11-16 17:18:47 UTC  

But not everyone pays taxes.

2017-11-16 17:18:51 UTC  

ID's cant be that expensive

2017-11-16 17:19:04 UTC  

yes but everyone will eventually pay taxes at some point

2017-11-16 17:19:08 UTC  

Not true.

2017-11-16 17:19:12 UTC  

even if its sales tax

2017-11-16 17:19:40 UTC  

unless you live in the woods foraging in which case you probably don't have an ID anyway

2017-11-16 17:21:10 UTC  

So you're assuming that we'll be able to cover at least the IDs just fine because naturally everybody has to pay state sales tax.

2017-11-16 17:21:45 UTC  

if an ID is needed to vote the state should supply them free of charge

2017-11-16 17:22:23 UTC  

What about Oregon? They have no sales tax.

2017-11-16 17:22:24 UTC  

naturally they can't be willed into existence so it will be paid for by tax

2017-11-16 17:22:41 UTC  

So how do they pay for the IDs out of everyone's pocket fairly?

2017-11-16 17:22:46 UTC  

i'm sure they can find the $10 a person they need to make some ID's

2017-11-16 17:23:20 UTC  

Should they charge you $10 for your ID at he DMV?

2017-11-16 17:23:27 UTC  

I mean, you're gonna pay it anyway in sales tax, right?

2017-11-16 17:24:30 UTC  

no, because then you are creating a financial barrier to voting

2017-11-16 17:25:14 UTC  

No, the financial barrier is there no matter where you put it.

2017-11-16 17:25:23 UTC  

That's a pretty basic economic principle.

2017-11-16 17:25:40 UTC  

When politicians say they're going to reduce the cost of healthcare, they don't really mean that.

2017-11-16 17:26:12 UTC  

It's not possible at actually reduce the cost of the healthcare without actually making the service less valuable.

2017-11-16 17:26:16 UTC  

of course

2017-11-16 17:26:20 UTC  

You can only relocate the cost.

2017-11-16 17:26:30 UTC  

im making a special case for things which are actual rights

2017-11-16 17:26:46 UTC  

like voting

2017-11-16 17:26:55 UTC  

i think financial barriers are infringement

2017-11-16 17:27:09 UTC  

what if the state decided to charge $10,000 for ID's? whats stopping them?

2017-11-16 17:27:17 UTC  

then only the super rich would vote.

2017-11-16 17:27:31 UTC  

this is obviously an extreme case

2017-11-16 17:27:49 UTC  

What I'm saying is you literally cannot eliminate the cost. It has to go somewhere.

2017-11-16 17:27:55 UTC  

likewise infringing on the second amendment by requiring permits, stamps etc which are prohibitively expensive