Read up on it tbh

There's a lot that could be said is faulty about catholic baptism compared to orthodox baptism

But is it valid?

That is the question.

Protestant baptism is faulty

But it is valid

Trinitarian baptism is all that is required imo

Anything else is donatism

Anyway i gtg sleep

Its 2:30 am for me

Night

What does Donatism have to do with Baptism? A quick googling doesn't immediately make that connection obvious

Goodnight

oh wait found a better source

Basically

A sacrament is valid if it's done trinitarian

Hence any trinitarian baptism is valid

And there is no need, nor should you be rebaptised

Its like converting to orthodoxy and getting remarried to your wife

I don't think all orthodox churches do it too

Seems like a quirk I'd have to do more reading into

But I'm not going to say no to the three dunks

There is no "rebaptism" because there are no sacraments outside the church
Historically trinitarian heretics were baptised and every other form of Christian is a trinitarian heretic because of filioque, Nestorianism, etc
Some are only chrismated through economy of a bishop and the chrismation is considered to give validity to their false baptism outside the church

It's not donatism, it's no sacraments outside the church

Sacraments aren't magic spells anyone can perform
Apostolic authority is required
And only clerics of the one holy catholic and apostolic church have this authority

@ChuuniMage @Crux

Too bad that the Orthodox have apostolic authority too

What Elijah said.
Also, i did learn a week ago from an Orthodox priest that laymen can perform baptism, although chrismation can be performed only by the clergy.
It's something to be used in extreme cases only.

"too"
Only the holy orthodox church has apostolic authority

Orthodox are just prots who wanted a cool name.

^ Kek'd

Isn't there something to do with the validity of baptism, though?

No

None of their sacraments are valid.

Not the argument I was making

The point I was asking about was isn't there a process of "rebaptism" when the validity of your baptism is called into question?

Remember goyim baptisms arent valid because some autist in the 21st century says the filioque is ebil because then he cant larp <:orthokike:291522285020512256>

"It is true that Christ's baptism is holy; and although it may exist among heretics or schismatics, yet it does not belong to the heresy or schism; and therefore even those who come from thence to the Catholic Church herself ought not to be baptized afresh"

<:cathokike:291522267890974721>

<:cathokike:291522267890974721>

<:rubbetirub:492691976081375242>