Message from @Larbi

Discord ID: 612404399410511873


2019-08-17 21:50:11 UTC  

most things are subjective, yes indeed

2019-08-17 21:50:24 UTC  

**we can logically derive our course of action from our goals and have them be objectively true for said set of goals**

2019-08-17 21:51:50 UTC  

that's not objective though, it's specific to each individual's goals

2019-08-17 21:52:01 UTC  

It's an objective way of attaining ones goals..

2019-08-17 21:52:14 UTC  

Logic is a way of constructing truth conserving statements

2019-08-17 21:52:20 UTC  

but it's not, because someone else may achieve the same goal in a different way

2019-08-17 21:52:34 UTC  

Then there are multiple solutions, yet the contrary cannot be the case

2019-08-17 21:52:46 UTC  

We can map solutions to efficiency, limit it down

2019-08-17 21:52:57 UTC  

we can map solutions dialectically to environment and people and limit it down

2019-08-17 21:53:14 UTC  

There are 'true' methods of reaching goals that ensure those goals are met given the assumptions hold.

2019-08-17 21:53:27 UTC  

valid

2019-08-17 21:53:39 UTC  

things can be valid but not objective

2019-08-17 21:53:48 UTC  

So what does objective mean to you?

2019-08-17 21:54:01 UTC  

Based on A priori?

2019-08-17 21:54:48 UTC  

in this context, `Not dependent on the mind for existence; actual.`

2019-08-17 21:54:56 UTC  

Then I suppose I've been conflating: Valid, Absolute and Objective.

2019-08-17 21:55:08 UTC  

language is a shithead sometimes lol

2019-08-17 21:55:10 UTC  

So objective - not dependant on mind for existence; actual.

2019-08-17 21:55:25 UTC  

Absolute - based on the mind and yet cannot be showcased to not be the way it is without the mind

2019-08-17 21:55:25 UTC  

there are multiple uses of the word, to be fair

2019-08-17 21:56:26 UTC  

Valid - given a objective or mental assumption, a statement that holds validity

2019-08-17 21:56:28 UTC  

in any case, I believe everyone is entitled to their own thought process, so long as you're not harming others :P

2019-08-17 21:57:55 UTC  

Sure, but I'd wish people to not hold ideas as absolutes. I suppose that means people that do so are misguided to me, but that may be my opinion. I wouldn't know unless there is objective evidence that can be gathered through studies, but then even the 'progress' of those studies depend on my goals and values of which are opinions.

2019-08-17 21:58:50 UTC  

the mind is a fickle thing 😂

2019-08-17 21:59:00 UTC  

Yup xD

2019-08-17 21:59:09 UTC  

good convo though 👍

2019-08-17 21:59:15 UTC  

Yh great talk 👍

2019-08-17 22:05:47 UTC  

@Phobia "evidence and facts aren't relevant here"

Phobes, if the relevant question is "Is there any god?", then that IS a scientific question about reality, and not merely an opinion.

If you have no evidence and facts to support your belief in a god, then that belief is irrational.

It's like me believing in a magical invisible dragon that protects me from all harm... but when I get harmed it was because the dragon knew it was best for me in the long run to get harmed that one time.

That's a pretty inoffensive belief that doesn't affect anyone, but it's still fully irrational.

2019-08-17 22:11:14 UTC  

in a discussion where neither side can prove or disprove their point, nothing is relevant 😉

2019-08-17 22:11:26 UTC  

that's why I say spiritual debates are a waste of time

2019-08-17 22:11:39 UTC  

Why are scientific debates of value?

2019-08-17 22:11:50 UTC  

let people believe what they will, so long as they're not hurting others

2019-08-17 22:11:59 UTC  

Why should they not hurt others?

2019-08-17 22:12:28 UTC  

because science is the study of the physical world

2019-08-17 22:12:45 UTC  

we're talking about issues entirely contained in the mind

2019-08-17 22:12:55 UTC  

So god is an issue of the mind and not the physical world?

2019-08-17 22:13:00 UTC  

correct

2019-08-17 22:13:07 UTC  

So god has no impact in the physical world?

2019-08-17 22:13:09 UTC  

he's not here, he's not tangible

2019-08-17 22:13:36 UTC  

No, and he says as much 😉

2019-08-17 22:13:48 UTC  

if he had an impact free will would be tainted