What you mean?

ok now watch the damn movie

@Sq crcl

If something is made as an adapation such as Netflic's The Witcher, one should rate the show based on it's quality as an independant piece of media rather than rating it's accuracy to the previous material.

Or am I wrong?

Judging an adaptation as an adaptation means judging how close it followed the source material, no? That's kinda separate from whether the show itself was well made in and of itself

ratings tell people what to expect

comments help in a better way

usually the two go hand in hand

Absolutely Xenon. But then should you leave out how good of an adaptation it is on your rating. There is a difference between rating the adaptation and rating the overall quality, no?

@Maeldryn

LOL

is that what your getting served?

for ads i mean?

For example: Triss looks and acts nothing like she does outside of the show but this cannot be leveled against the quality overall as without viewing extra material you wouldn't know or expect anything of Triss.

Don't cover it man, not a shame

I include it because the show makers themselves said how much they wanted to honor the source material, and tbh I wanted the definitive witcher story, not some avant gard interpretation of it

Oh shit, you did say it was a subjective rating, sorry. My bad.

https://fox8.com/2019/06/16/alabama-orders-chemical-castration-of-some-child-molesters/

Lol

Have a good one, friend!

I completely agree with this

how does this law punish women?

cant remove a penis is she doesnt have one

Chop the ovaries

Chemical castration dude

You don't chop off the penis lmao

Or mutilate the ovaries

@Titrainium even if I rated it the other way I would still give it basically the same score because the parts that stayed from the source material are actually the weaker parts of the show, such as ciris arc being dragged out and altered slightly to fit 8 episodes

Y not tho?

remove the peepee

Strayed**

That's fair

Chemical castration is a legal body chemical treatment that has been used since around 1944 to reduce the level of testosterone in men, and also in women, seeing as the hormone triggers the sex drive in both.

if pedophelia is a mental illness, should we remove their brains? 🤔

@Rhys yes