@Maksim I was only making the argument because some dumbfuck said they were a financial drain

You can't preserve culture. Culture has always changed, regardless of the ethnic make-up of your country and it will continue to do so

I mean it doesn’t matter because migrants aren’t beneficial to any capacity unless you are a capitalist @Maksim

@adolphus the sorrowful we don’t say culture can’t change or shouldn’t, however it changing is very different than mass migration which will basically see out right replacement more than any cultural diffusion saying oh it changes doesn’t mean we should flood our country with foreigners. Secondly historically when people mass flooded a area or cams with a lot of violence to to bring about a large cultural shift but we got to ignore that part don’t we. Thirdly it is already proven increased diversity shows a decrease in civic engagement. Fourthly what will happen. Is they come here and their own culture is destroyed for liberal capitalist consumerism.

My fucking face when a communist is advocating for mass migration which destroys the ability for labor to organize decreases the wage of workers and makes competition harder for them and ultimately only benefits the capitalist class

I'm not advocating for mass migration lol I recognize the problems with it. I just think "preserving culture" is arbitrary and retarded. YOU attributed that to me. But anyways

Immigration isn't inherently beneficial to capitalists

Especially when it isn't under a capitalist system

Yes it is

When then it can’t be because there aren’t any capitalist

If it's a socialist society it isn't capitalist

That's how

But we don’t oppose cultural change we just oppose a drastic replacement of a nation and the death of its culture

It's not replacement though

They don’t even defuse

The great replacement has been thoroughly debunked

Cut that bs pls

Incorrect

So any data?

That hasn't been thoroughly discredited

America went from 90% white to 60% eh it e and of all children under three more than 50% are minority

Hmm yes we have declined by about 40% from 1965 due to mass migration please tell me how whites aren’t being replaced @adolphus the sorrowful

I bet the brookings institute is a bunch of racist

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2018/03/14/the-us-will-become-minority-white-in-2045-census-projects/amp/

So how has it been debunked

So it isn't actually cultural replacement. Its racial. And this doesn't mean that whites literally shrunk as a group. They just have less of a share of the population because after immigration (specifically 1965) reform, the population grew exponentially

None of this points to whites being "replaced", except that last article which I bet

That’s why it’s called replacement numbnut you are just trying to argue semantics

No I'm not. It literally isn't replacement

The population is just growing

Whites are still@there

Not being replaced

More people are just coming in

ok so if i add water to whisky then its still the same?

Not comparable

kinda is doe

Yeah they aren’t literally taking whites and replacing them with a non white but they are replacing whites as the dominate demographic

Secondly it is comparable

We aren’t the same we are different

People aren’t just these interchangeable parts you can move around